Tyler Robinson’s defense attorney has faced criticism after making a pointed remark about Charlie Kirk’s widow, Erika Kirk, during a major pre-trial evidence hearing in Utah.
Michael Burt made the comment while arguing against the public release of certain evidence connected to the assassination case, claiming that widespread access to details could influence a future jury pool.
The defense attorney said Erika had been “very adept at holding press conferences” where she had discussed details surrounding the investigation, a statement that immediately drew condemnation from those representing the Kirk family.
Lawyer Argues Public Release of Evidence Could Affect Jury Selection
The dispute arose as the Kirk family pushed for greater transparency in Robinson’s upcoming legal proceedings.
Family representatives urged the court to release unredacted versions of evidence, witness statements and surveillance footage presented by prosecutors, arguing that the public had a right to see the material.
Burt opposed that request, warning that releasing sensitive evidence could make it more difficult to find an impartial jury if the case proceeds to trial.
During his argument, he referenced Erika Kirk’s public appearances following her husband’s death.
“I want to point out to the court, Ms. Kirk has been very adept at holding press conferences in which she has revealed evidence,” Burt said.
He added that Erika had suggested the state was acting as her legal representative and argued she was “perfectly free” to publicly discuss what prosecutors believed the evidence showed.
Kirk Family Attorney Accuses Defense of Misrepresenting Situation
The remarks quickly became a flashpoint inside and outside the courtroom.
An attorney representing the Kirk family accused Burt of presenting a “complete distortion of reality,” arguing that his criticism unfairly targeted a grieving widow who had spoken publicly after the killing.
The comment also triggered strong reactions online, with critics describing Burt’s statement as inappropriate and “outrageous.”
The backlash came during an already emotional week of hearings, where both families have witnessed disturbing testimony and evidence connected to the September 2025 killing.
Erika Kirk Becomes Emotional During Court Proceedings
Hours before Burt’s controversial statement, Erika Kirk was reportedly heard crying inside the courtroom while prosecutors presented evidence against Robinson.
The hearing included references to an alleged apology message Robinson sent to his former roommate and partner, Lance Twiggs, following the shooting.
The courtroom atmosphere became increasingly tense as prosecutors continued presenting their case, outlining evidence they say links Robinson to the assassination.
Prosecutors Present Evidence They Say Connects Robinson to Killing
During the hearings, prosecutors have detailed several pieces of evidence they claim support their case against Robinson.
Among the evidence presented were DNA findings from a towel allegedly connected to the firearm used in the shooting, alleged admissions made by Robinson and testimony from Twiggs.
Prosecutors also showed footage of Twiggs’ police interview, where he described his relationship with Robinson and recalled events surrounding the day Kirk was killed.
Former Partner’s Testimony Reveals Details About Robinson’s Alleged Actions
Twiggs, 23, told investigators that he first met Robinson in 2023 when they became roommates before beginning a romantic relationship several months later.
According to court testimony, Twiggs said Robinson left early on the morning of Kirk’s assassination, telling him he needed to work a long shift.
Twiggs said he did not hear from Robinson again until later that night, when Robinson allegedly instructed him to look beneath his keyboard, where he found a handwritten note.
Court filings stated the note allegedly contained a message saying Robinson had the opportunity to kill Kirk and intended to do so.
Twiggs told investigators that Robinson returned home the following morning and appeared anxious, pacing around the house while avoiding questions about the killing.
He later claimed Robinson confessed, became emotional and said he regretted what had happened.
Courtroom Reacts to Details About Alleged Weapon Evidence
The testimony from Twiggs also created emotional moments for both families.
When Twiggs discussed alleged engravings found on bullet casings and said Robinson had used a Dremel tool connected to hunting activities, members of Robinson’s family reportedly reacted strongly.
Court observers said Robinson’s brother lowered his head and appeared overwhelmed, while his mother comforted him by rubbing his back.
The Kirk family also reacted during Twiggs’ testimony, reportedly expressing disbelief as details of the interview were played in court.
Judge Appears Affected While Watching Footage of Shooting
The hearings also included previously unseen footage of Charlie Kirk’s killing, creating a tense moment inside the courtroom.
Utah District Judge Tony Graf was seen watching the footage during proceedings and appeared visibly affected by what he witnessed.
The courtroom reportedly fell silent as the video played, with the judge visibly reacting to the disturbing images.
Judge Will Decide Later Whether Case Moves Forward to Trial
Robinson’s probable cause hearings are designed to determine whether prosecutors have enough evidence to proceed with a full murder trial.
The proceedings function as a preliminary review rather than a trial, meaning prosecutors only need to demonstrate probable cause rather than prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Judge Tony Graf is expected to issue his decision in September 2026 on whether the case will move forward.
Until then, Robinson is expected to remain in custody while awaiting the court’s ruling.
If the case proceeds and Robinson is convicted, prosecutors have indicated they intend to seek the death penalty.
