In a picturesque coastal city in California, homeowners are finding themselves at odds over the proliferation of short-term rentals like Airbnb.

Tensions are rising as residents face challenges linked to these rental properties, leading to heated debates and conflicting viewpoints.

Homeowners Push for Fewer Restrictions

In Pacifica, a group of local residents is advocating for looser regulations on short-term rentals.

Their main concern is financial, as they rely on the income from these rentals to help cover their mortgage payments.

The ability to rent out properties on platforms like Airbnb is seen by some as a necessary source of income.

The Other Side of the Debate

Conversely, many Pacifica locals are calling for stricter regulations on short-term rentals.

They cite issues such as disruptive parties, overflowing trash, and parking congestion as major problems.

Jeff Jones, an 80-year-old resident, shared his frustrations with the local news, mentioning that he has called 911 about 35 times in the past four years due to noisy guests at a nearby rental property.

The disturbances have significantly impacted his quality of life, with loud parties often occurring on the deck of the rental property, visible and audible from his own home.

Personal Stories of Disruption

Caitlin Quinn, a beachfront property owner for seven years, expressed her distress to KRON4.

She described how her home life has been marred by constant disturbances, including luggage being dragged under her bedroom window at all hours.

Quinn believes the rental permit for her neighbor’s property should have been revoked, citing being woken up 50 times between midnight and 5 am as a significant issue.

Patricia Kephart, 67, echoed similar concerns, noting that she frequently sees trash scattered around street collection bins, left behind by guests of short-term rentals.

She described it as an “ongoing parade” of unfamiliar faces that makes her feel unsafe.

Data on Complaints

Recent data from the city reveals that just four homes were responsible for half of the 66 complaints filed against rentals in the past year.

This statistic highlights the concentration of issues among a few properties, rather than being a widespread problem across all short-term rentals.

Financial Impact on Property Owners

Amidst these concerns, Wayne Thai and his wife, who moved to Pacifica in 2019, are arguing against stricter restrictions.

They purchased a $1.3 million home on Milagra Drive but had to relocate due to family obligations.

They now list the property on Airbnb and Vrbo, earning approximately $70,000 annually from the rental.

This income is crucial for them, as it helps with home improvements and mortgage payments.

Thai is concerned about the possibility of losing their home and is seeking a solution that balances the interests of both renters and permanent residents.

What’s Next?

As the debate continues, the community is left grappling with how to address the conflicts between those benefiting from short-term rentals and those facing disruptions.

The city will need to find a balanced approach that addresses the concerns of all residents while considering the financial needs of property owners.