England’s World Cup campaign may have ended in a narrow semi-final defeat to Argentina, but the post-match debate has quickly shifted to the performances of key players.
Former Scotland captain and outspoken pundit Graeme Souness has delivered a blunt assessment of England’s midfield, arguing that Declan Rice and Elliot Anderson fall short of the standard required to dominate at the highest level.
Souness Draws Sharp Comparison With Rodri
Speaking after England’s elimination, Souness contrasted the Three Lions’ midfield duo with Spain’s midfield leader Rodri, whom he described as the benchmark for the modern central midfielder.
According to Souness, Rodri consistently drives his team forward with intelligent passing and quick decision-making rather than carrying the ball unnecessarily or opting for safe sideways passes.
He suggested that Spain’s Ballon d’Or-winning midfielder demonstrates the creativity and vision he believes England’s midfield currently lacks.
Rice and Anderson Branded Too Predictable
Souness reserved particularly strong criticism for Declan Rice, claiming the Arsenal midfielder has likely reached his peak and is unlikely to develop further at 27 years old.
While he acknowledged Elliot Anderson’s age leaves room for improvement, he also questioned the Newcastle academy graduate’s ability to influence games in the final third.
In Souness’ view, both players are effective at retaining possession and recycling the ball but fail to produce the kind of incisive passing or attacking imagination needed to trouble elite opponents.
Suggestion That Rice May Be Better Suited Elsewhere
The former Liverpool midfielder went even further by suggesting Rice’s qualities might be better suited to central defence rather than midfield.
Despite Rice often being described as a world-class midfielder, Souness argued that his strengths lie more in his athleticism, defensive work, and commitment than in his creativity on the ball.
He maintained that top central midfielders should read the game quickly enough to move the ball efficiently instead of advancing long distances before being forced into safe passes.
Praise Amid the Criticism
Although his overall verdict was harsh, Souness made it clear that his comments were not directed at Rice’s professionalism or work ethic.
He praised the England international’s determination, physical attributes, and willingness to give everything throughout matches, describing his attitude and commitment as beyond question.
His criticism focused solely on what he considers shortcomings in Rice’s technical and creative qualities as a midfielder.
Rice Overcame Physical Setbacks During Tournament
Rice’s performances in the United States came despite dealing with several physical challenges throughout England’s World Cup journey.
Before the semi-final against Argentina, he recovered from illness after battling a sickness bug while the squad was based in Miami.
The midfielder also managed ongoing hamstring discomfort and back pain during the tournament but remained an ever-present figure in Thomas Tuchel’s starting lineup, featuring alongside Anderson in every match as England reached the final four.
Debate Over England’s Midfield Continues
England’s exit has reignited discussion over whether the current midfield possesses the creativity required to compete with the world’s strongest teams.
Souness’ comments are likely to fuel further debate, particularly as Tuchel begins assessing his squad ahead of future international competitions.
While Rice’s resilience and consistency earned praise during the tournament, questions over England’s ability to control matches through midfield are expected to remain a major talking point in the aftermath of their World Cup disappointment.
Summary
Graeme Souness has launched a scathing critique of England midfielders Declan Rice and Elliot Anderson after the Three Lions’ World Cup semi-final defeat to Argentina.
While praising Rice’s commitment and professionalism, Souness argued that neither midfielder possesses the creativity or vision displayed by Spain star Rodri, suggesting Rice may even be better suited to playing in central defence.
Despite battling illness and injuries throughout the tournament, Rice remained a key figure in Thomas Tuchel’s squad as England reached the semi-finals.
What’s Next?
Attention now turns to Thomas Tuchel’s post-tournament review as England begin preparations for upcoming international fixtures.
Souness’ outspoken assessment is likely to intensify scrutiny of England’s midfield options and could spark renewed calls for greater creativity in the team’s central areas ahead of the next major tournament.
