It was a dramatic moment in Manchester City’s ongoing battle for a Champions League spot as they faced Aston Villa. City had gotten off to a dream start, going 1-0 up early on thanks to a goal from Bernardo Silva.
However, what followed turned the game on its head, especially after a key decision that left City’s manager, Pep Guardiola, visibly frustrated.
The Controversial Penalty Decision
Things took a turn in the first half when Aston Villa’s Jacob Ramsey was involved in a tussle in the City box with Ruben Dias.
Referee Craig Pawson initially waved play on, but the situation quickly caught the attention of VAR official John Brooks.
After reviewing the incident, Brooks recommended a review of the referee’s call, which ultimately resulted in a penalty being awarded to Aston Villa.
VAR Intervention and Guardiola’s Protest
While the contact between Dias and Ramsey was subtle, replays showed that there was indeed a trip, despite Dias signaling with his hands that he had no intention of making contact.
Guardiola, frustrated by the decision, mimicked Dias’ actions on the touchline, clearly upset by the reversal of the referee’s initial call.
The Premier League later released a statement explaining the reason behind the decision.
According to the league, VAR deemed there was a clear trip and recommended the on-field review, leading to the penalty being awarded.
Sky Sports Pundits Weigh In on the Decision
Despite the boos ringing out inside the Etihad, Sky Sports pundits Roy Keane and Shay Given agreed with the referee’s decision.
Keane argued, “He takes him out… he has no chance of getting the ball.
Pep is frustrated, but it is a penalty.” Given also chimed in, noting that while there was a slight touch on the ball, it didn’t negate the fact that it was a foul. “It is a foul, the right decision,” he concluded.
Manchester City’s Setback and the Race for Top Four
The decision came at a crucial time for Manchester City, who were looking to secure a third-place finish in the Premier League with a win.
However, the match had been brought forward due to the FA Cup semi-finals, meaning City would have played one more game than their competitors.
Villa, on the other hand, had the chance to leapfrog City into fourth place with a victory, adding further importance to the match.
This controversial penalty only added more tension to an already high-stakes encounter as both teams vie for crucial points in the race for the top spots in the Premier League.