As the summer transfer window swings open, all eyes are on Manchester United’s goalkeeping position.
After a challenging season, there’s growing debate about whether Andre Onana still deserves to be the club’s No. 1 next term.
Former Premier League keeper Ben Foster has weighed in, suggesting that United might need to make a change between the sticks.
Andre Onana’s Struggles Cast Doubt on His Future at Old Trafford
Onana arrived at Manchester United in 2023 from Inter Milan for a hefty £47 million fee, but last season didn’t go as smoothly as hoped.
Despite his talent, the Cameroonian keeper made several high-profile errors that cost the team dearly.
Across 34 Premier League games, he managed just nine clean sheets and conceded 44 goals, contributing to a disappointing 15th-place finish for the Red Devils.
Backup Options Haven’t Inspired Confidence Either
It’s not just Onana who’s under pressure—backup goalkeeper Altay Bayindir has also struggled to impress, which leaves United in a tricky spot.
The club could be ready to let Onana go before securing a new first-choice goalkeeper, signaling a major shake-up in their defensive lineup.
Ben Foster Urges United to Pursue Emiliano Martinez
Former goalkeeper and pundit Ben Foster recently spoke to talkSPORT about the situation.
He said, “The Premier League is brutal, and over the last couple of seasons, Onana hasn’t really done enough to prove he’s the No. 1 at Manchester United.
He’s talented, but I think he might do better somewhere else.”
Foster added that if United gets the chance to sign Aston Villa’s Emiliano Martinez, they should take it without hesitation.
“Martinez is still one of the best keepers in the world, and you need a strong spine in your team.
Getting the goalie right is a huge part of that.”
Manchester United’s Interest in Martinez Has History
Reports from Argentine news outlet TyC Sports reveal that United showed interest in Martinez earlier this year.
The club reportedly reached out to Aston Villa in January but ultimately stuck with Onana—for now.
However, speculation is rife that Martinez could be on the move this summer, as Villa look to comply with the Premier League’s strict financial regulations.
Martinez’s Emotional Farewell and Uncertain Future
Martinez, 32, seemed emotional during Villa’s final home game of the season, a 2-0 victory over Tottenham.
Fans sensed a farewell as he was visibly moved, and he even received a red card in his last match after a collision with United’s Rasmus Hojlund.
When asked about his future ahead of Argentina’s World Cup qualifiers, Martinez kept things open, saying, “The transfer window just opened, so there’s still a long way to go.”
For now, his priority remains his national team duties.
What’s Next for Manchester United’s Goalkeeper Spot?
With the transfer market heating up, Manchester United face a big decision.
Will they back Onana to bounce back, or will they push ahead to bring in a proven shot-stopper like Martinez?
One thing is clear—strengthening that goalkeeper position is key if United want to climb back up the Premier League table next season.