Racially Profiled” or Hygiene Policy? Tribunal Dismisses Muslim Doctor’s Claims, Emphasizes Workplace Courtesy

A heated argument between a Muslim doctor and her nursing colleagues at a hospital was not motivated by religion, according to a recent employment tribunal ruling.

Dr. Farhat Butt, who wears a hijab and covers most of her body, claimed she was racially profiled and bullied after being asked to roll up her sleeves for hygiene purposes.

Hygiene Policy at the Center of Dispute

Dr. Butt worked as a visiting consultant ophthalmologist at Airedale General Hospital.

The hospital enforced a “bare below the elbows” hand hygiene policy in clinical areas.

However, the policy also acknowledged cultural and religious needs, offering disposable sleeves as an alternative.

Dr. Butt argued that the distinction between clinical and non-clinical areas was unclear.

Escalated Encounter in the Corridor

On the day in question, Dr. Butt was spotted by the director of nursing, Mary Hytch, with her sleeves rolled down in a non-clinical corridor.

Hytch politely asked Dr. Butt to roll up her sleeves, which Dr. Butt perceived as a challenge.

The situation escalated quickly, with raised voices on both sides.

Dr. Butt felt targeted and cancelled her surgeries for the day.

Tribunal Dismisses Discrimination Claims

Dr. Butt filed a complaint alleging religious discrimination and harassment.

However, the tribunal judge ruled that the argument stemmed from a misunderstanding of the hygiene policy, not Dr. Butt’s religion.

The judge acknowledged that the incident was stressful for Dr. Butt and the escalation could have been avoided by both parties.

Lessons Learned

This case highlights the importance of clear communication in the workplace.

Employers should ensure policies are well-defined and staff are aware of exceptions for cultural or religious needs.

Employees should also be encouraged to raise concerns calmly and professionally.

Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn