Lindsay Clancy will face a second trial over the deaths of her three children after a judge scheduled fresh proceedings for March 29, 2027.
The new trial date was agreed upon by prosecutors and the defence during a court hearing at Plymouth Superior Court in Massachusetts on Monday, November 16.
Judge William Sullivan also scheduled a final pretrial conference for February 18, 2027, while a status conference is expected to take place on December 30, 2026.
The decision follows the collapse of Clancy’s first trial in September, when jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict, resulting in a mistrial.
Prosecutors Signal Intention to Pursue First-Degree Murder Charges
During Monday’s hearing, Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague indicated that prosecutors intend to proceed with first-degree murder charges against Clancy.
“Given what the charges are, it requires a jury trial,” Sprague told the court.
She explained that charges of second-degree murder or lower could allow Clancy to request a bench trial, in which a judge rather than a jury determines the verdict.
The prosecution’s position indicates that the state intends to maintain the original first-degree murder charges when the case returns to court.
Scheduling Disagreement Emerges Between Judge and Prosecutors
The hearing also featured a disagreement over when the retrial should begin.
Prosecutors pushed for a later date, with Sprague explaining that other murder cases, including some dating back several years, were still awaiting trial.
She told the court that she had a 2014 criminal case scheduled for April.
Judge Sullivan had instructed both sides to select a date in March or April, eventually settling on March 29, 2027.
The timing is significant because Sullivan is due to retire in June 2027 under mandatory retirement rules.
A delay beyond his retirement could mean that another judge would have to take over the proceedings.
Tense Exchange Between Judge Sullivan and Prosecutor
A brief confrontation occurred during discussions about the trial schedule.
Sprague appeared frustrated after Sullivan made comments while speaking with defence attorney Kevin Reddington about possible dates.
“I don’t have any jokes,” the prosecutor said.
Sullivan responded that he was not joking but was attempting to discuss scheduling arrangements with both legal teams.
The hearing subsequently concluded after the prosecution and defence reached an agreement on the new trial date.
Clancy’s First Trial Ended in a Hung Jury
Clancy, 36, is accused of killing her three children, Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan, in January 2023.
She admitted to strangling the children but pleaded not guilty to murder by reason of insanity.
Her defence has maintained that she was experiencing severe postpartum psychosis at the time of the killings and had been overmedicated by doctors.
The first trial ended in September after the jury remained divided 11 to one in favour of acquittal. With the jurors unable to reach a unanimous decision, the judge declared a mistrial.
Judge Rejects Motion to Dismiss Murder Charges
Monday’s hearing came a week after Sullivan rejected a defence motion seeking to dismiss the murder case.
The judge also prohibited Reddington from investigating the juror who refused to vote for Clancy’s acquittal during the first trial.
The identity of the holdout juror was subsequently reported as 48-year-old Michael Desronvil.
In his first interview following the mistrial, Desronvil described Clancy’s actions as methodical and said he believed the killings were deliberate.
Clancy’s defence lawyer had also raised allegations that Desronvil misrepresented previous domestic violence allegations during the jury selection process.
Defence Previously Challenged Holdout Juror’s Conduct
The dispute surrounding the holdout juror had already created tension during a November 2 court appearance.
During that hearing, Sullivan interrupted Reddington as he attempted to make arguments concerning the juror.
“I’m going to stop you right there,” the judge said.
Reddington responded, “No, you’re not going to stop me.”
Sullivan subsequently threatened to end the hearing and warned against disclosing the juror’s name.
Reddington argued that the juror had received more media attention than he had following the conclusion of the trial.
Clancy’s Supporters Gather Outside Courthouse
Several supporters of Clancy were also spotted at the Massachusetts courthouse ahead of Monday’s proceedings.
The group wore pink clothing as a show of solidarity with the accused mother and to raise awareness of maternal and women’s mental health issues.
Clancy’s parents also arrived at the courthouse during the hearing.
The next major court appearance in the case is scheduled for December 30, 2026, ahead of the February 18 pretrial conference and the March 29, 2027 retrial.