Nottingham Triple Murder Inquiry Rocked by New Police Blunders Over Missing Phone and Undisclosed Evidence

Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo
Published

Nottinghamshire Police are facing fresh criticism over their investigation into the Nottingham attacks after admitting that officers failed to examine a Nokia mobile phone belonging to triple killer Valdo Calocane for three years.

The device was discovered inside a pocket of Calocane’s holdall, which had been in police possession. Officers reportedly failed to notice the phone until recently, when relatives of the victims questioned the force about items recovered from the bag.

The latest revelation has prompted renewed anger from the families of Ian Coates, Barnaby Webber and Grace O’Malley-Kumar, who described the continuing emergence of investigative failures as ‘gobsmacking’.

Although forensic examination of the phone reportedly found no information of significance, the families have questioned how such an important item could have remained unexamined for so long.

Police Discover Phone Following Questions From Victims’ Families

The Nokia handset was reportedly rediscovered after the victims’ relatives contacted Nottinghamshire Police to seek clarification about an item contained in Calocane’s holdall.

An officer subsequently searched the bag’s pockets again and found the device, which had apparently gone unnoticed throughout the first three years of the investigation.

The discovery came months after evidence hearings at the public inquiry into the attacks had concluded, prompting further questions about the police investigation.

Nottinghamshire Police confirmed that it was aware of the matter and was providing evidence to the inquiry.

A force spokesperson said: “We are aware of these matters and are providing evidence to the inquiry in relation to them. In the circumstances, we are not able to comment further at the moment.”

Grace O’Malley-Kumar’s Father Raises Concerns Over Forensic Failures

The discovery of the phone follows further allegations that investigators failed to carry out forensic examinations on other potential evidence connected to the attacks.

Grace O’Malley-Kumar’s father, Dr Sanjoy Kumar, said police had also acknowledged that they did not forensically examine a pole used by Calocane during the attacks, despite the weapon appearing in CCTV footage.

He questioned why investigators had not conducted a complete fingerprint analysis to establish whether anyone else could have been involved.

Speaking about the alleged failure, Dr Kumar said: “It’s unimaginable to me as a parent that in a multiple homicide a full and thorough fingerprint analysis has not been done to rule out accomplices.

This represents an absolutely botched investigation.”

The Times also reported that Nottinghamshire Police had misplaced a sensitive document connected to the case without immediately informing the public inquiry.

Sensitive Police File Left in Taxi After Inquiry Hearing

The missing document was reportedly lost by an officer who had given evidence at the inquiry.

The officer is said to have left the file inside a taxi while travelling from a railway station to a pub.

Although the document was recovered several hours later and senior officers were informed, the inquiry was reportedly not notified immediately.

The incident has raised concerns among the victims’ families about a possible data breach and the handling of confidential information.

Barnaby Webber’s mother, Emma Webber, questioned whether the incident had been referred to Nottinghamshire Police’s professional standards department for investigation.

Reacting to the latest developments, she said: “It just gets worse and worse. It is gobsmacking.

They did not do their jobs before the attacks, and they didn’t do them afterwards.”

The police force confirmed that it was aware of the incident and was providing relevant evidence to the inquiry, but declined to comment further.

Police Previously Apologised Over Undisclosed Notebooks

The latest controversy follows Nottinghamshire Police’s apology in September for failing to disclose notebooks belonging to Calocane that contained lists of bomb-making ingredients.

The material, which was recovered from bins and a holdall at a property from which Calocane had recently been evicted, included references to explosives such as acetone peroxide, also known as TATP or Mother of Satan, and Semtex.

The notebooks also contained mathematical equations, drawings, deeply misogynistic writings and references to the Manchester Arena attack.

Despite the contents, investigators initially decided the material did not have sufficient evidential value to warrant disclosure.

The documents were eventually provided to the public inquiry after lawyers representing the bereaved families identified a reference to them in a police statement.

Their disclosure came only weeks ago, after the inquiry’s evidence hearings had already concluded.

Rachel Langdale KC, counsel to the inquiry, said it would have been obvious that the material was relevant to the investigation.

The notebooks had also not been provided to the Crown Prosecution Service or psychiatrists involved in assessing Calocane.

Undisclosed Evidence Affected Decisions Over Criminal Proceedings

The failure to disclose the notebooks has raised further questions about the decisions that led to Calocane avoiding a murder trial.

The material was not considered by the psychiatrists who assessed his mental state or by prosecutors before the recommendation that he should be allowed to plead guilty to manslaughter by diminished responsibility.

A judge subsequently accepted the recommendation, resulting in Calocane being ordered to remain indefinitely in a secure mental health hospital.

The decision angered the victims’ relatives, who had wanted him to face a murder trial and receive a prison sentence.

Calocane was responsible for the deaths of 65-year-old school caretaker Ian Coates and University of Nottingham students Barnaby Webber and Grace O’Malley-Kumar during a series of attacks in June 2023.

He also seriously injured three other pedestrians after using a van to ram them during the incident.

Families Were Not Warned About Alleged Stalker

Further concerns emerged after reports that police failed to inform the bereaved families about a mentally ill man who allegedly developed a fixation on the Nottingham attacks.

The unnamed individual reportedly absconded from a mental health hospital before travelling to Barnaby Webber’s family home in Somerset and the GP surgery where Grace’s father worked.

Despite being aware of the man’s movements, police allegedly failed to alert the families.

Officers were said to have played down the potential threat because the individual was reportedly attempting to help the grieving relatives.

The incident prompted Nottinghamshire Police to refer itself to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC).

The watchdog is already investigating several potential failures connected to Calocane’s case, including how he remained at large despite an outstanding arrest warrant relating to an earlier matter.

Previous Attacks and Police Contacts Come Under Scrutiny

The public inquiry has also examined the police and mental health services’ handling of Calocane before the June 2023 killings.

Investigators have faced questions over why he was not arrested despite previous incidents involving attacks on neighbours and forcing entry into a woman’s flat.

CCTV footage showing Calocane attacking a warehouse worker several months before the triple killings emerged in September after lawyers uncovered it.

The inquiry was also told that footage showing him attacking co-workers at a factory in Leicestershire five weeks before the murders had been deleted.

The deletion was attributed to human error.

At the beginning of the inquiry, a family liaison officer reportedly presented a timeline to one of the survivors that suggested police had not been made aware of Calocane before the attacks.

However, the timeline allegedly excluded 11 previous police dealings involving the attacker.

Sophie Cartwright KC, representing survivors at the inquiry, said the apparent withholding of relevant information appeared to have been considered at the highest levels of Nottinghamshire Police.

Fifteen NHS Workers Dismissed Over Access to Victims’ Records

The investigation has also extended to the handling of confidential medical information.

Fifteen NHS employees have reportedly been dismissed in recent weeks after accessing the victims’ medical records inappropriately.

The development has added to the concerns surrounding the treatment of sensitive information connected to the case.

Dr Sanjoy Kumar said the families had continued to encounter new revelations since losing their daughter.

He said: “Since we lost Grace, it has been one shock after another, one failing after another.”

He also expressed concern about information suggesting Calocane may have been considering further attacks, including possible bombings in Nottingham.

Nottinghamshire Police Rejects Suggestions of a Cover-Up

Nottinghamshire Police has faced repeated allegations over its handling of the investigation, including claims that relevant evidence was withheld from the inquiry and other authorities.

John Beggs KC, representing the force, acknowledged that there had been communication failures.

However, he rejected suggestions that the police had deliberately concealed information.

He said it was “simply not correct to suggest a cover up”.

The public inquiry continues to examine the actions of Nottinghamshire Police and mental health services before and after the June 2023 attacks, as the families seek answers over the failures that allowed Calocane to remain free and the subsequent handling of evidence.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo profile photo

About Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo

A performance driven and goal oriented young lady with excellent verbal and non-verbal communication skills. She is experienced in creative writing, editing, proofreading, and administration. Oluwasewa Badewo is also skilled in Customer Service and Relationship Management, Project Management, Human Resource Management, Team work, and Leadership with a Master's degree in Communication and Language Arts (Applied Communication).