Lizzie Henderson, the woman who previously planned to marry convicted family murderer Chris Watts, has spoken about the fallout from their relationship after the engagement ended earlier this year.
The 39-year-old former real estate agent was recently found working at a grocery store in Racine, Wisconsin, after relocating from Ohio. She told the Daily Mail that the publicity surrounding her relationship with Watts had placed her in a difficult position and affected her personal life.
Henderson no longer wears the diamond engagement ring she was previously seen with. Instead, a band tattoo now appears on her left ring finger.
Henderson Says Publicity Put Her in a Difficult Position
When approached by the Daily Mail at her workplace, Henderson initially greeted the reporter with a hug and said she was doing well.
However, she became reluctant to discuss Watts, saying there was much more to what had happened after their relationship became public.
She said she did not want to revisit the subject because it had put her in a negative light.
Henderson also suggested that the attention surrounding the relationship had caused difficulties within her family.
She maintained that the criticism and messages she received after being identified as Watts’ fiancée had frightened her more than the prospect of being engaged to a convicted murderer.
According to Henderson, some of the messages she received would have scared an ordinary person, although she said her religious beliefs remained strong.
Religious Beliefs Remain Central to Henderson’s Explanation
During the conversation, Henderson repeatedly referred to her faith and described God as the guiding force behind her decisions.
Asked whether she remained in contact with Watts, she responded that her actions were motivated by her relationship with God.
She also appeared to suggest that she was willing to offer spiritual support to people in need, regardless of their circumstances.
Henderson said she believed that speaking to someone about God had not put her in danger, but that the reaction to her relationship had.
She also disputed the suggestion that her earlier comments about the Watts murders showed a lack of empathy.
During an August interview, she had described the killings as something harsh for anyone to experience. She later told the Daily Mail that she was aware of the seriousness of the crimes and had not intended to offend anyone.
Relationship With Watts Ended After Engagement Became Public
The Daily Mail first reported earlier this year that Henderson and Watts were attempting to marry while he served five consecutive life sentences at Dodge Correctional Institution in Wisconsin.
Watts was convicted of murdering his pregnant wife, Shanann Watts, and their two young daughters in August 2018.
Henderson had moved from Ohio to Wisconsin and visited him repeatedly during 2025. The visits included Christmas Day, when the pair were reportedly seen kissing and exchanging declarations of love.
However, the relationship ended just weeks after news of their engagement became public. Reports at the time said Watts had cut off contact with Henderson following objections from his mother, Cindy Watts.
Henderson’s Move to Wisconsin and Employment
Records indicate Henderson previously worked as a real estate agent in Ohio before relocating to Wisconsin in 2024.
She initially lived in Sturtevant before moving to the Concord Apartments complex in Racine in August 2025. Prison records showed she made at least 20 additional visits to Watts during that year.
The apartment complex’s rental company’s attorney later confirmed that Henderson had been evicted by New Year’s Day. Her current living arrangements were not established in the report.
Henderson continues to hold an active real estate licence with a nationwide company in Wisconsin, although the company’s Racine office had no record of her employment when the newspaper visited.
She rejected the suggestion that she had moved to Wisconsin specifically to be closer to Watts, saying she had chosen to work there after receiving a promotion.
The Daily Mail also reported that she relocated with her elderly mother, whom she helps care for.
Henderson said the publicity had not affected her grocery store job and that she remained on cordial terms with colleagues.
One coworker described her as a friendly employee who was willing to offer people a hug when they needed one.
Author Who Corresponded With Watts Questions His Religious Commitment
Henderson has previously spoken about religion when explaining how her relationship with Watts began. An eyewitness also reportedly saw Watts holding a Bible while speaking with her during a prison visit.
However, true crime author Cherlyn Cadle, who has corresponded with Watts for several years and written a book about him, questioned the sincerity of his religious beliefs.
Cadle described Watts as a sex addict who uses religion as a public front and said information emerging about his behaviour had continued to raise concerns.
Reports Raise Questions About Watts’ Relationships With Male Inmates
The latest developments follow reports that Watts had allegedly pursued sexual relationships with male prisoners while maintaining contact with women outside prison.
A prison employee claimed that Watts had recently been separated from another inmate over suspicions of an inappropriate relationship.
The employee also alleged that younger prisoners competed for Watts’ attention and that he gave potential partners gifts purchased through the prison commissary.
A former inmate told the Daily Mail that Watts had written lengthy letters to younger men and described his own connection with the convicted killer as intimate.
The former prisoner said the two had been close, while declining to confirm the full nature of their relationship.
The allegations follow a 2020 disciplinary incident in which prison guards reportedly discovered Watts’ underwear, petroleum jelly, baby oil and other personal items inside another inmate’s cell.