BBC Apologizes for Handling of Martin Bashir’s Diana Interview
The BBC has issued an apology for what it acknowledges as “errors” in its management of disclosure related to Martin Bashir’s interview with Diana, Princess of Wales. The broadcaster faces accusations of failing to release material under Freedom of Information (FOI) law concerning its handling of the scandal when it surfaced in 2020.
Allegations of a “Cover-Up”
During closing remarks at a tribunal tasked with deciding whether details should be disclosed under FOI law, documentary maker Andrew Webb, who originally exposed Mr. Bashir, characterized the BBC’s actions as a “cover-up.” Even Diana’s brother, Earl Spencer, was called upon to provide evidence in the case.
The Scandal Unfolds
The scandal came to light after the then head of news at the BBC, Lord Hall of Birkenhead, privately suggested that Earl Spencer had provided Mr. Bashir with bank statements. It was later revealed that Bashir had breached the BBC’s producer guidelines by fabricating bank statements and presenting them to Earl Spencer in 1995 to secure access to Diana.
Compromise Reached
Mr. Webb and the BBC have now reached an agreement in which the documentary maker will be allowed to review a sample of documents. This compromise came about after Mr. Webb initially expressed dissatisfaction with the broadcaster’s failure to release over 3,000 emails related to its handling of the scandal.
Doubts and Questions
In his closing statement, Mr. Webb expressed his doubt about the accuracy of the BBC’s statements, particularly regarding the serious allegations made against Earl Spencer. He emphasized the need to verify the facts directly with Earl Spencer, leading to a conversation that left him convinced that the BBC’s account was incorrect.
Accusations of Selective Disclosure
Mr. Webb raised concerns about whether the BBC selectively released documents, presenting what they deemed “good stuff” while withholding what they considered “bad stuff.” He explained that his FOI request was initiated to uncover the truth.
Allegations of Covering Up the Past
Mr. Webb suggested that BBC executives aimed to “revive” the 1996 cover-up and protect Martin Bashir from accountability. He expressed his belief that the BBC’s actions were intended to ensure that Bashir would never face consequences for his actions.
BBC’s Response and Apology
Representing the BBC, barrister Jason Pobjoy admitted that mistakes had been made but emphasized they were made in “good faith.” He offered an apology on behalf of the BBC for these errors while maintaining that the mistakes were not intentional.
The case surrounding Martin Bashir’s interview with Princess Diana continues to unfold, with the BBC acknowledging its lapses in handling the matter.