Tether Fires Back at S&P After USDT Receives Lowest Stability Rating Over Rising Reserve Risks

Samantha Allen
Published

Tether has challenged a decision by S&P Global Ratings to maintain its lowest stability assessment for USDT, after the ratings agency raised concerns about the stablecoin’s reserve composition, transparency and regulatory safeguards.

In an assessment published on November 18, S&P retained its rating of 5, classified as weak, for USDT’s ability to maintain its peg to the US dollar.

The rating is the lowest on the agency’s five-point scale and remains unchanged from November 2025, when S&P first downgraded the stablecoin.

Tether rejected the assessment, arguing that the agency’s evaluation framework was responsible for the negative conclusion rather than weaknesses in the company’s reserves.

In responding to the findings, the company also referred to The Big Short, the film about the 2008 financial crisis, while questioning the reliability of traditional financial risk assessments.

Higher-Risk Assets Make Up 28% of USDT in Circulation

S&P identified the growing proportion of higher-risk assets in Tether’s reserves as a major concern.

According to the agency, Bitcoin, gold, publicly traded equities, secured loans and corporate bonds accounted for approximately 28 per cent of USDT in circulation as of September 30.

The proportion had increased from 24 per cent a year earlier, indicating greater exposure to assets whose market values can fluctuate.

S&P warned that a substantial decline in the value of these holdings could leave USDT undercollateralised, particularly if several categories of reserve assets suffered losses simultaneously.

Tether’s September 30 reserve report, attested by BDO, showed approximately $191.5 billion in assets against $183.5 billion in liabilities.

The figures indicated that the company held around $7.95 billion in excess assets beyond its reported liabilities.

Although S&P highlighted the additional risks identified in its assessment, it did not reduce the rating further because USDT had already received the lowest possible score.

S&P Raises Questions About El Salvador’s Regulatory Framework

The ratings agency also questioned the regulatory arrangements governing Tether in El Salvador, where the company relocated in January 2025.

El Salvador’s National Commission of Digital Assets requires 70 per cent of reserves to be held in assets that can be liquidated within 30 days.

However, S&P said the regulatory framework was broadly defined because it allows assets such as Bitcoin, gold and loans to qualify despite their exposure to market and liquidity risks.

The agency also raised concerns about the absence of a requirement to separate Tether’s reserve assets from its other corporate holdings.

According to S&P, regulatory frameworks in the United States and Europe generally provide stronger expectations for the segregation of stablecoin reserves.

The agency said publicly available information did not establish whether Tether’s reserve assets were sufficiently separated from its wider corporate holdings, leaving uncertainty about their protection against other business-related risks.

Independent Audit Disclosure Remains Under Scrutiny

Tether’s financial reporting has also remained a point of disagreement with the ratings agency.

In August 2026, KPMG issued an unqualified opinion on Tether’s 2025 accounts, which the company described as its first full independent audit.

Tether presented the development as evidence supporting the reliability of its financial reporting.

However, S&P said the audited financial statements and the auditor’s report had not been made publicly available, limiting its ability to independently examine the underlying financial information.

The agency also noted that Tether’s reserve disclosures did not identify the custodians and counterparties responsible for holding its assets.

Its reserve attestations are published quarterly, while some competing stablecoin issuers provide updates every month.

Tether Previously Challenged S&P’s Assessment

The latest disagreement follows an earlier dispute between Tether and S&P after the agency downgraded USDT in November 2025.

Tether chief executive Paolo Ardoino criticised the assessment in a post on X, saying the company wore the criticism with pride and referring to previous financial collapses as evidence of weaknesses in traditional financial systems.

The company has continued to dispute the agency’s approach to assessing stablecoin reserves and financial risks.

Despite maintaining its lowest stability rating, S&P acknowledged that USDT had demonstrated a strong record of maintaining its price stability, particularly over the preceding 12 months.

The latest assessment therefore leaves USDT with the same weak rating while highlighting concerns about the growing share of higher-risk reserve assets, the transparency of its holdings and the safeguards governing its reserves.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Samantha Allen profile photo

About Samantha Allen

Samantha Allen is a seasoned journalist and senior correspondent at TDPel Media, specializing in the intersection of maternal health, clinical wellness, and public policy. With a background in investigative reporting and a passion for data-driven storytelling, Samantha has become a trusted voice for expectant mothers and healthcare advocates worldwide. Her work focuses on translating complex medical research into actionable insights, covering everything from prenatal fitness and neonatal care to the socioeconomic impacts of healthcare legislation. At TDPel Media, Samantha leads the agency's health analytics desk, ensuring that every report is grounded in accuracy, empathy, and scientific integrity. When she isn't in the newsroom, she is an advocate for community-led wellness initiatives and an avid explorer of California’s coastal trails.