Man United’s £70m Carlos Baleba Gamble Under Scrutiny as Midfield Struggles Continue

Malcolm Hemsworth
Published

Manchester United midfielder Carlos Baleba has attracted significant attention following his summer move from Brighton, despite playing less than two hours of Premier League football since joining the club.

The 22-year-old made his first Premier League start for United against Leeds, having previously come off the bench against Tottenham after recovering from early-season injury concerns.

Baleba has been praised for his first touch, passing ability and awareness of space and timing. However, the growing expectations surrounding the midfielder have raised questions about the pressure being placed on him so early in his United career.

Manager Michael Carrick described his midfield as “terrific” and “fantastic” following the draw at Leeds, although United’s overall performance continued to highlight the team’s difficulties in controlling matches.

United’s £150m Midfield Investment Faces a Major Test

Baleba’s reported £70m transfer from Brighton formed part of a major midfield rebuild during the summer transfer window.

United also spent £50m on Andrey Santos from Chelsea and £35m on Youri Tielemans from Aston Villa, taking their reported investment in the three midfielders beyond £150m.

The spending reflects the club’s efforts to strengthen the central areas of the team after years of difficulty controlling games through possession.

However, United’s recruitment plans are understood to place greater emphasis on strengthening the defence next summer, leaving the current midfield group with the responsibility of delivering improvements during the 2026/27 campaign.

The investment has increased the importance of Baleba and his fellow midfielders establishing themselves as reliable performers.

Leeds Possession Statistics Highlight United’s Problems

United’s 1-1 draw against Leeds exposed continuing difficulties in controlling possession.

Leeds recorded 61 per cent of the ball at Elland Road, leaving United unable to dominate the match despite their status as a leading Premier League club.

The performance continued a pattern in which United have struggled to dictate games through possession, relying instead on counter-attacking opportunities.

Carrick described the match as a “fresh start”, but the draw left United with seven points from their opening seven Premier League fixtures.

The club’s position has increased scrutiny of its performances following last season’s improvement under Carrick.

Amazon Documentary Adds to the Attention Surrounding United

Carrick has spoken about blocking out external criticism as he attempts to address United’s current problems.

However, the club is also allowing an Amazon documentary crew access behind the scenes, while a journalist continues working on a book about Manchester United’s efforts to return to the top of English football.

United are reportedly receiving around £20m for granting Amazon access to the club.

The amount is approximately one-quarter of the revenue a club receives for qualifying for the Champions League, according to the report.

Carrick will be hoping that the filming and attention surrounding the club do not interfere with his efforts to improve performances.

Daniel Farke Awaits Clarity Over His Leeds Contract

Leeds manager Daniel Farke has guided the club to a strong start to the Premier League season, with the team sitting seventh after losing just one of its first seven matches.

The German manager, 49, took charge after previous spells managing Norwich City and has continued to establish himself in the Premier League.

His current contract expires at the end of the season, although a new agreement is reportedly at an early stage.

A contract extension would provide clarity over Farke’s future as he continues to lead Leeds following their return to the top flight.

A mural outside Elland Road pays tribute to former manager Marcelo Bielsa, who guided Leeds into the Premier League in 2020 but was unable to maintain their top-flight status.

James Trafford’s Progress Raises Questions About Manchester City’s Goalkeeper Decision

James Trafford’s performances for Leeds have renewed attention on Manchester City’s decision to sell the goalkeeper during the summer.

The Cumbrian joined Leeds from City for a reported £40m after previously playing regularly for Burnley in the Premier League.

During his spell at Burnley two seasons ago, Trafford struggled with crosses and commanding his penalty area.

His performances have since improved, and England head coach Thomas Tuchel is among those who believe Trafford could become a contender to succeed Jordan Pickford as the national team’s first-choice goalkeeper.

Trafford’s development has prompted comparisons with Gianluigi Donnarumma, who is now playing for Manchester City, and raised questions about whether City made the right decision in selling the English goalkeeper.

Manchester City Show Progress Under Enzo Maresca

Manchester City’s performances under Enzo Maresca have attracted attention despite the continuing scrutiny surrounding the club’s legal dispute with the Premier League.

City have recorded 100 shots across their first seven league matches this season, compared with 84 at the same stage of the previous campaign under Pep Guardiola.

The figures include a match against Manchester United in which City managed only six shots while playing with 10 men.

Maresca’s squad depth was also evident against Ipswich, when he rested first-choice midfielders Elliot Anderson and Enzo Fernandez, as well as Rayan Cherki.

City still secured a 3-2 victory, with Phil Foden scoring once and Erling Haaland adding two goals.

‘Red Cartel’ Accusation Continues to Fuel Tensions

Disagreements over media coverage of Manchester City’s legal battle with the Premier League have continued to surface on social media and around matchdays.

Some members of the broadcast media with reported connections to other clubs have faced criticism while working near the touchline at the Etihad Stadium before matches.

One prominent presenter was accused of belonging to a “f***ing red cartel”.

The report noted that, as far as was known, the presenter was not a member of the commission that delivered the guilty verdicts in the case.

Ron Atkinson’s Wrong-Dugout Mistake Becomes a Football Anecdote

Arsenal’s victory over Nottingham Forest prompted a reminder of a story involving former manager Ron Atkinson during a previous visit to the City Ground.

Arsenal won the match 1-0 in January 1999, shortly after Atkinson had been appointed Nottingham Forest manager in an attempt to prevent relegation.

Before kick-off, Atkinson mistakenly sat in the wrong dugout.

He later joked about the error by recalling that he turned around and saw Dennis Bergkamp and Marc Overmars sitting nearby.

Atkinson said he wondered how the Arsenal players could be in the bottom three, unaware initially that he had taken the wrong seat.

Set-Piece Rules Draw Criticism After Liverpool Incident

Football’s rules governing penalties and fouls at corners have come under criticism following an incident involving Brentford’s Yehor Yarmolyuk and Liverpool’s Jeremy Jacquet.

Yarmolyuk was sent off for headbutting Jacquet during Saturday’s match, but Liverpool were not awarded a penalty.

The report questioned the rule that prevents a penalty or foul from being awarded during the preparatory stages of a corner before the ball is in flight.

It also raised concerns about the physical holding and pushing between players that regularly occurs before set-pieces are delivered.

Howard Webb Reveals 70-Page Report on Haaland Goal

Howard Webb, head of Professional Game Match Officials Limited, has spoken about what he believes is a gradual improvement in refereeing standards.

In an interview with The Sunday Times, Webb revealed that he requested a report on Erling Haaland’s controversial goal in the Manchester derby in September, which was incorrectly allowed to stand.

The report was compiled by Spanish VAR consultant Vicandi Garrido and reportedly ran to 70 pages.

Webb’s comments have brought renewed attention to the review process used to examine controversial refereeing decisions.

David Moyes Defends Everton Tackle Despite Rule Changes

Everton manager David Moyes defended Harrison Armstrong’s tackle on Chelsea’s Josh Acheampong, saying it was the kind of challenge that spectators would have appreciated.

Moyes acknowledged that the tackle would have been considered fair during his playing days as a centre-back.

However, the report noted that modern football laws have changed and that Armstrong’s challenge failed to meet at least two of the relevant criteria.

Moyes also told the BBC that he had not watched the incident before commenting on it.

Diego Gomez’s Long-Range Goal Compared With Beckham’s Famous Strike

Brighton midfielder Diego Gomez scored a long-range goal during his side’s 5-0 victory over Crystal Palace, prompting comparisons with David Beckham’s famous strike for Manchester United against Palace in 1996.

Gomez’s effort came from 56 yards, around 20 yards closer to goal than an earlier attempt he made against Sunderland the previous week.

The goal was notable for the limited time Gomez had to look up, the absence of a substantial run-up and the short backswing before striking the ball.

Newcastle’s Changes to Blaydon Races Prompt Questions

Newcastle United have introduced a revised version of the local anthem Blaydon Races before matches at St James’ Park.

The club said the changes were intended “to preserve the song’s legacy while strengthening its impact inside the stadium”.

The revised version has prompted discussion among supporters familiar with the traditional song, which has been played at the stadium for many years.

The changes were highlighted in a match report by journalist Craig Hope, drawing further attention to the club’s decision to alter a long-established part of its matchday atmosphere.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Malcolm Hemsworth profile photo

About Malcolm Hemsworth