Controversial Victory: Ukrainian Model Crowned Miss Japan Amidst Backlash
In a move that has ignited a storm of controversy, Carolina Shiino, a 26-year-old woman born in Ukraine, secured the title of Miss Japan, becoming the first naturalized Japanese citizen to claim this prestigious crown.
The pageant took place in Tokyo on Monday, January 22, raising questions and criticisms surrounding the criteria for a non-Japanese native to hold the title.
A Background of Diversity: Miss Shiino’s Journey to Japan
Originally born to Ukrainian parents, Carolina Shiino moved to Japan at the age of five when her mother married a Japanese man.
Despite her diverse background, Shiino emphasized her Japanese identity, expressing gratitude for being recognized as a Japanese person in the Miss Japan Grand Prix pageant.
Striving for an Inclusive Society: Shiino’s Vision and Acceptance Speech
In her acceptance speech, Miss Shiino conveyed her commitment to breaking barriers and fostering an inclusive society where people are not judged based on their appearance.
She declared herself Japanese in both speech and mind, embracing her role as a representative of Japanese beauty.
Online Backlash: Criticisms and Questions on National Identity
Despite Shiino’s assertions, her victory triggered a wave of criticism online. Many questioned how a person with no Japanese ancestry could rightfully hold the title of Miss Japan.
Concerns were raised about the selection criteria, with some suggesting a potential preference for Western looks over Asian features.
Debating the Criteria: War in Ukraine and the Perception of Beauty
Some online comments linked the controversy to geopolitical events, speculating whether Shiino’s Ukrainian background played a role in her victory.
Criticisms surfaced, asserting that if she were born Russian, the outcome might have been different.
The debate extended to broader questions about the perception of Japanese beauty and the impact of political decisions on pageant results.
Organizer’s Response: Reimagining Japanese Beauty Standards
Ai Wada, the organizer of the pageant, defended Shiino’s victory as an opportunity to rethink Japanese beauty standards.
She emphasized that Japanese beauty transcends appearance and blood, asserting that it firmly resides in the heart.
This response echoed a similar sentiment expressed in 2015 when Ariana Miyamoto, with a mixed ethnic background, faced controversy upon winning the Miss Japan title.Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn