UK Youth Jobs Crisis: Alan Milburn Proposes National Insurance Cuts for Businesses Hiring Under-25s

Larry John Brown
Published

Businesses employing workers aged between 21 and 24 should receive gradual reductions in National Insurance contributions over five years to encourage the creation of more jobs for young people, according to an independent review led by former Labour minister Alan Milburn.

The report, which has been under development for a year and is due to be published on Tuesday, recommends beginning the reductions in sectors such as retail and hospitality.

Milburn proposes doubling the earnings threshold at which employers start paying National Insurance for workers in this age group from £5,000 to £10,000.

However, he says the changes should only be introduced when the country’s financial position allows.

The review argues that an immediate reduction across all businesses would not be the most effective use of public money given the UK’s current fiscal circumstances.

Nearly One Million Young People Outside Work or Education

The report will examine ways to address the number of young people who are not in employment, education or training, commonly referred to as NEETs.

Office for National Statistics figures show that nearly one million people aged between 16 and 24 fall into this category.

Milburn estimates that the government spends approximately £22bn annually supporting young people who are economically inactive.

He will argue that the increase in employer National Insurance introduced by the government was not the original cause of youth unemployment, although he believes reducing employment costs could help businesses recruit more young workers.

Proposed Changes to Universal Credit and Disability Benefits

The review is also expected to recommend changes to benefits available to people under 25.

Milburn proposes removing access to the health element of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment (PIP) for under-25s.

He will also call for a legal guarantee that young people receive an offer of employment, training or employment support.

Under the proposed system, those who refuse to accept available assistance could face the loss of their benefits.

Milburn is expected to argue that providing young people with training and skills will have limited value if suitable employment opportunities are not available.

Immediate National Insurance Cut Could Cost £5.1bn

Research by the Resolution Foundation estimates that immediately removing employer National Insurance contributions for workers aged 21 to 24 would cost approximately £5.1bn.

Milburn believes a gradual approach would be more appropriate than introducing an immediate reduction across the economy.

Under the current rules, employers do not pay National Insurance contributions for workers under 21 or apprentices under 25 unless their annual earnings exceed £50,270.

For non-apprentices aged between 21 and 24, businesses pay employer National Insurance at 15 per cent on annual earnings above £5,000.

These arrangements took effect in April 2025 after former Chancellor Rachel Reeves increased the rate from 13.8 per cent and reduced the payment threshold from £9,100.

Nottingham Hairdresser Says Employment Costs Are Limiting Recruitment

Collette Osborne, who owns three hair salons in Nottingham, said rising employment expenses, including National Insurance and minimum wage payments, have made it increasingly difficult to recruit and train young workers.

She previously employed eight apprentices each year but said she can no longer afford to take on apprentices.

Her workforce has also fallen by more than half to 21 employees.

Osborne told the BBC that training an apprentice costs approximately £60,000 before they can begin working with customers.

She said applications from young people seeking employment have increased, but financial pressures prevent her from offering them positions.

Osborne added that some parents had even offered to pay their children’s wages to help them secure employment at her salons.

She said she felt overwhelmed by employment costs and did not believe businesses were receiving sufficient support to recruit young people.

Milburn Supports Wage Subsidies for Businesses

Speaking on the BBC’s Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg programme, Milburn supported government assistance for businesses that employ young workers.

He said the state should consider subsidising wages to make it easier for employers to recruit people who may need additional support when entering the workplace.

Milburn pointed to mental health difficulties, ADHD and anxiety among some young jobseekers, saying smaller businesses should not be expected to absorb all the associated costs.

He said government support could help employers manage these challenges.

Minimum Wage Changes Raise Further Concerns

Milburn also backed Chancellor John Healey’s decision to slow the planned equalisation of minimum wage rates across different age groups.

Labour had pledged in its manifesto to remove age-based pay differences and narrow the gap between adult minimum wages and rates for workers aged 18 to 20.

However, Healey announced in the Budget that the minimum wage for 18 to 20-year-olds would rise from £10.85 to £11.27 an hour in April next year.

For workers aged 21 and above, the rate will increase from £12.71 to £13.21 an hour.

Milburn said he understood the need to prevent young workers from receiving poverty-level wages but warned that bringing the rates closer together placed additional financial pressure on the government.

He called for a careful examination of how quickly the minimum wage rates should converge.

Government Extends Subsidised Jobs Guarantee

Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden announced on Sunday that the government would expand its subsidised jobs guarantee for Universal Credit claimants aged between 18 and 24.

Under the revised eligibility rules, young people who have received benefits for 12 months will qualify, compared with the previous requirement of 18 months.

The scheme will operate across England, Scotland and Wales and provides eligible participants with a guaranteed six-month job.

McFadden said the programme was expected to help more than 90,000 young people enter employment by March 2029.

Conservatives Demand Lower Business Taxes

Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Helen Whately criticised the government’s approach, arguing that reducing employment taxes would be more effective than taxing businesses and subsequently subsidising jobs.

She said the Conservatives wanted to halve employer National Insurance costs.

Whately added that businesses had told her they wanted to recruit young people but could no longer afford to do so because of employment expenses and regulations introduced under Labour.

Retail and Hospitality Identified as Starting Points

Milburn’s review recommends that any gradual reduction in employer National Insurance should initially focus on businesses in retail and hospitality.

The two sectors account for 37 per cent of jobs held by people aged between 16 and 24 in the UK.

The proposed changes are intended to reduce recruitment costs in industries that employ significant numbers of younger workers while addressing the wider challenge of youth unemployment.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Larry John Brown profile photo

About Larry John Brown

Larry John is a talented writer and journalist based in New York, USA. He is a valued contributor to TDPel Media, where he creates engaging and informative content for readers. Larry has a keen interest in current events, business, and technology, and he enjoys exploring these topics in-depth to provide readers with a comprehensive understanding of the issues. His writing style is characterized by its clarity, precision, and attention to detail, which make his articles a pleasure to read. Larry’s passion for storytelling has earned him a reputation as a skilled writer and a respected authority in his field.