Royal Expert Robert Hardman Dissects Lilibet Naming Controversy on The Reaction Talkshow
In the latest episode of “The Reaction,” Mail columnists Sarah Vine and Andrew Pierce engage in a riveting conversation with esteemed royal author Robert Hardman.
The focus of discussion centers on the ongoing row sparked by Prince Harry and Meghan Markle’s decision to name their daughter Lilibet.
Insights into Queen’s Fury: Robert Hardman’s Revelations
Robert Hardman, renowned for his insights into royal affairs, sheds light on the turmoil surrounding the naming of Lilibet.
Drawing from his exclusive serialization of “Charles III: New King. New Court. The Inside Story,” Hardman discloses that the Queen was left furious by the public fallout following the Sussexes’ choice of their daughter’s name.
Hardman quotes a former member of the late monarch’s staff, describing the Queen as ‘angry as I’d ever seen her.’
Handling of Naming Revelation: Legal Warnings and Palace Standoff
The controversy deepened when it was reported that the Queen had not been asked about using her childhood nickname.
Subsequently, the Sussexes resorted to legal warnings, seeking endorsement for their version of events.
However, the Palace was reluctant to validate their claims, leading to a standoff.
Hardman emphasizes that attempts to put words in the Queen’s mouth were unsuccessful, resulting in the Sussexes retracting their legal threats.
Critique from Sarah Vine: Suggestions for a More Respectful Approach
Columnist Sarah Vine interjects with a critique, suggesting that Prince Harry and Meghan Markle could have shown more respect to the late Queen by using Lilibet as a middle name instead.
She raises concerns about the cumulative impact of their decisions, referencing previous issues, documentary controversies, and accusations of racism within the Royal Family.
Contradictions in Naming Choice: Vine Questions Decision Amid Royal Exit
Vine highlights what she perceives as a contradiction in the Sussexes’ decision-making. Having expressly left the Royal Family, she questions their choice to name their daughter in a way that seems contradictory to their initial decision.
The discussion revolves around the appropriateness of appropriating a unique Royal name, acknowledging the risk of public reactions.
Robert Hardman and Conclusion: Risks Involved in Unique Royal Names
Hardman concurs with the potential risks involved in appropriating a unique Royal name like Lilibet.
While acknowledging the couple’s right to keep the naming private, he emphasizes that the uniqueness of the chosen name invites a heightened public response.
The trio concludes by discussing King Charles’ reign and his sure-footed approach to challenges.
The Reaction Talkshow: Weekly Insights on Controversial Topics
“The Reaction,” a new YouTube talk show, offers Mail’s star writers’ insights on the biggest topics of the day.
In the second episode, Vine and Pierce delve into Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s challenges and discuss the ‘nuclear’ reaction to Donald Trump’s victory in the first Republican primary in Iowa.
In summary, “The Reaction” provides an in-depth exploration of current affairs, with the Lilibet naming controversy taking center stage in the latest episode, offering unique perspectives from royal expert Robert Hardman and Mail columnists.