Mixed Reactions to Vogue’s Supermodel Cover: From Discontent to Celebration

Mixed Reactions to Vogue’s Supermodel Cover: From Discontent to Celebration


Vogue magazine is facing backlash from its fans over the airbrushing of iconic supermodels, including Cindy Crawford, Linda Evangelista, Naomi Campbell, and Christy Turlington, for a joint September issue cover for both Vogue and British Vogue.

While the initial announcement of the Nineties supermodel lineup delighted fashion enthusiasts, the cover’s creative direction has sparked controversy and disappointment.

The Criticism

Alexandra Shulman, former editor of British Vogue from 1992 to 2017, expressed her disappointment in a piece for the Mail on Sunday, criticizing how the magazine had transformed these legendary figures into “cartoon versions” of themselves.

Shulman questioned the decision to present them in heavily retouched and stylized appearances, dressed in somber attire.

Many individuals on social media echoed her sentiments, noting that the airbrushing took away from the natural beauty and relatability of the supermodels.


Backlash on Social Media

Social media platforms were flooded with critiques regarding the cover’s artistic direction.

Users on Instagram and Twitter voiced their opinions, with some feeling that the cover was a missed opportunity to showcase the genuine beauty of the supermodels.

They questioned the choice of dark colors and the overall presentation against a silvery grey background, asserting that the creative direction lacked the vibrancy and excitement expected from such iconic figures.

Discontent with Photoshop Use

Some fans also expressed concern about the apparent use of Photoshop, particularly in relation to Cindy Crawford’s appearance.

Certain individuals found her facial features significantly altered and questioned the authenticity of the image.


This aspect of the cover design led to further disappointment and speculation about the extent of digital manipulation.

Mixed Reactions and Hopeful Sentiments

Despite the criticism, there were those who expressed their excitement about the prominence of these legendary supermodels in the September issue.

Many fans welcomed the return of such iconic figures to the cover, as opposed to the trend of featuring newer celebrities like the Kardashians.

They lauded the models for their enduring impact on the fashion industry and their representation of an era.

The Super Models Docuseries

The cover shoot, captured by photographer Rafael Pavarotti, was part of the promotion for the upcoming Apple TV+ docuseries titled “The Super Models.”


This four-part series, directed by Academy Award winner Roger Ross Williams and Larissa Bills, explores the careers and legacies of the supermodels from the 1980s to the present day.

The series delves into not only their contributions to the fashion world but also their activism, philanthropy, and business ventures, showcasing their influence on the next generation.

In conclusion, the joint September cover featuring Nineties supermodels for Vogue and British Vogue has ignited controversy due to the perceived airbrushing and creative direction.

Despite the criticisms, the cover has also sparked conversations about the enduring impact of these iconic supermodels and their upcoming docuseries, which aims to celebrate their contributions across various domains.

Read More On The Topic On TDPel Media

TDPel Media

This article was published on TDPel Media. Thanks for reading!

Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn

Advertisement: Download Vital Signs App (VS App)