Criminal Charges for Utah Man Accused of Trying to Ease Wife’s Suffering Through Choking

Criminal Charges for Utah Man Accused of Trying to Ease Wife’s Suffering Through Choking

DeWayne McCulla, a 45-year-old man from Utah, now faces criminal charges related to the attempted murder of his terminally ill wife, Arenda Lee McCulla.

The disturbing incident occurred while Arenda was receiving hospice care during her battle with breast cancer, ultimately leading to her passing in 2021.

The Alleged Crime:

DeWayne McCulla is accused of attempting to choke his late wife in the presence of six family members.

Charging documents reveal that family members had to intervene and pull him away during the incident.

McCulla, when questioned by La Verkin police, admitted to placing his hand over Arenda’s neck, claiming it was an attempt to ease her suffering as she faced the final stages of cancer.

The shocking nature of the alleged crime raises questions about the complexities of end-of-life situations and the emotional toll it takes on families.

The legal proceedings will likely delve into the motivations behind McCulla’s actions and the aftermath of the incident.

Charges and McCulla’s Admission:

DeWayne McCulla has been formally charged with attempted murder in the 5th District Court.

It remains unclear why charges are being brought two years after Arenda’s death.

McCulla, in discussions with the police, reportedly affirmed that he would repeat the act, emphasizing his love for his wife.

The admission by McCulla adds a layer of complexity to the case, as it raises questions about the perception of his actions and the justification he provides.

The legal system will scrutinize the circumstances surrounding the incident and assess the appropriateness of the charges brought against him.

Arenda’s Battle with Breast Cancer:

Arenda Lee McCulla faced a challenging battle with breast cancer, diagnosed in 2020, which later spread to her brain, neck, liver, and lungs.

The family endured the emotional and physical toll of her treatments, including radiation and chemotherapy, as detailed in updates on a GoFundMe page for medical expenses.

The heartbreaking details of Arenda’s health struggles shed light on the devastating impact of cancer and the toll it takes on both patients and their loved ones.

The legal proceedings will likely consider the context of Arenda’s illness in assessing the events leading up to the attempted murder.

Remembering Arenda:

Before falling ill, Arenda was an active member of her local community, known for her passion for mountain biking and her involvement in a youth rehabilitation center.

Originally from Binghampton, New York, she had been living in south Utah since 2005.

An obituary written by her son, Anthony Ryder, pays tribute to her role as a wife, mother, sister, and friend.

Arenda’s life and contributions to her community become part of the narrative surrounding the tragic incident.

The legal case not only involves the alleged crime but also the broader context of Arenda’s life and the impact on her family.


As DeWayne McCulla faces legal repercussions for the attempted murder charge, the family reflects on the trauma they endured during Arenda’s illness and her final moments.

The legal proceedings will unfold, seeking justice for the alleged crime while acknowledging the complex emotions surrounding end-of-life care.

The case prompts broader discussions about the ethical and legal aspects of end-of-life decisions and the emotional strain families experience in such challenging circumstances.

The courtroom will become the arena for navigating the complexities of compassion, suffering, and the boundaries of acceptable actions during terminal illnesses.

TDPel Media

This article was published on TDPel Media. Thanks for reading!

Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn

Advertisement: Download Vital Signs App (VS App)