In an unprecedented move, New Zealand-based cooperative Foodstuffs is proposing to integrate facial recognition technology into its North Island stores. The primary objective of this novel system is to compile biometric templates of customers, particularly those with a history of harmful behaviors, thereby establishing a more secure shopping environment.
Privacy and Surveillance Concerns
This initiative, however, has spurred scrutiny from the privacy commissioner and initiated widespread concerns regarding privacy infringement and the looming threat of a surveillance society. The technology has been criticized as invasive, akin to the unconsented collection of DNA data. Dr. Kate Bower, a renowned AI expert from the UTS Human Technology Institute, has expressed her concerns about the potential risks associated with racial bias and the broader implications of biometric data collection by a private entity.
Risks of Inaccurate Identification
She further emphasized the susceptibility of the technology to inaccuracies, especially in the identification of people of color. This perspective was echoed by Māori data ethicist Dr. Karaitiana Taiuru, who pointed out the technology’s imperfections, including disproportionately higher false accusation rates for Māori and Pacific peoples.
Data Storage and Access Queries
Queries regarding data storage, retention, deletion, and access by law enforcement agencies—both domestic and international—have been raised. Despite reassurances from Foodstuffs that images will be immediately deleted unless a crime is committed and that data will not be shared with third parties without a legal mandate, the public is encouraged to voice their concerns before such technologies become commonplace in public spaces.
Protective Measures in Place
The proposed system would exclude minors from its record of offenders, and a third-party evaluation of the trial has been planned to ensure its effectiveness and adherence to privacy standards. While Foodstuffs has made efforts to assuage public concern, the initiative remains a subject of considerable debate and caution.
Share on Facebook «||»
Share on Twitter «||»
Share on Reddit «||»
Share on LinkedIn
The Vulnerability of Facial Recognition: Which Smartphones Are Prone to Spoofing?: In the fast-evolving landscape of smartphone technology, security features play a pivotal role in safeguarding user data and privacy. However, a recent revelation by Which?...
Norfolk Southern Train Veers Off Tracks, Plunges Into Pennsylvania River, Prompting Environmental Concerns Amid CEO’s Soaring Pay: In a troubling incident, a Norfolk Southern freight train derailed near the 2200 block of Riverside Drive in Lower Saucon Township, Pennsylvania, on Saturday morning....
Breaking: Firefighters Battle Blaze at Onehunga; Smoke Concerns Rise: Auckland’s Green Gorilla waste management facility has been engulfed in a mammoth blaze since Wednesday afternoon. Firefighters in Auckland, equipped with heavy machinery and cutting-edge...
Breaking: CMA to keep ‘close eye’ on Google as it secures final Privacy Sandbox commitments: The CMA has secured legally binding commitments from Google to address competition concerns over its Privacy Sandbox CMA now moves into the next phase where...
The Ethics of Metaverse: Addressing Concerns About Privacy and Security: Reality and fiction blend in the Metaverse, and you’ve just stepped into it. The Metaverse has the potential to radically alter our day-to-day lives by...
Government Overreach Concerns Arise After FBI Search: Privacy vs. Security: FBI Search Triggers Privacy Debate A recent FBI search conducted last month has ignited concerns surrounding the extent of government overreach and has prompted a...
BBC Stands Firm: Defending Coverage of Kate Middleton’s Diagnosis Amid Backlash Over Privacy Concerns and Media Ethics: Amidst mounting criticism and public backlash, the BBC has taken a resolute stance in defense of its coverage of Kate Middleton’s diagnosis. Despite facing scrutiny...
Supermarkets Accused of Hiking up Prices on Fresh Produce: Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn...
Braai Essentials – Price Wars Heat Up Among South Africa’s Supermarkets: The joy of indulging in a classic braai outdoors on a weekend is unparalleled. However, the recent surge in prices for braai essentials, ranging from...
Frustrated Britons Lament Forgotten Membership Cards, Risking Higher Prices in Supermarkets and Cafes Across the UK: Walking into your local supermarket only to realize you’ve forgotten your membership card can be a frustrating experience. This scenario, known as “Clubcard rage,” has...
