Labour’s top pick for the next UK borders watchdog, John Tuckett, has sparked debate after revealing that he plans to work remotely—at least part of the time—from his home in Finland.
The 73-year-old, who was named last month as the government’s preferred candidate for the role of Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration, made the statement during a parliamentary hearing.
A Hybrid Approach to a High-Profile Role
During his confirmation hearing, Tuckett shared his vision for the job, suggesting a “60/40 split” between in-person duties and remote work.
He emphasized the importance of being present for key meetings and site visits but also highlighted the need for uninterrupted time to focus on report writing and strategic planning.
Despite living in Finland, Tuckett assured MPs that he would be available in London five days a week if necessary.
He also pointed out that, in his current role as Immigration Services Commissioner, he had successfully transitioned the department to a fully remote working model after the pandemic, calling it a “win, win, win.”
Concerns Over Remote Oversight
The idea of a senior official overseeing UK border security while living abroad has raised eyebrows.
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp criticized the arrangement, arguing that such a critical position requires a hands-on presence in the UK.
“It’s completely absurd to suggest that a public official can effectively carry out this role from hundreds of miles away,” Philp stated.
Labour MP Chris Murray also questioned Tuckett on his ability to inspect UK border operations while residing outside the country.
Tuckett responded by clarifying that, although he is officially a resident of Finland, he frequently travels to the UK for work and would continue to do so in this role.
He also mentioned that he would cover his own travel and accommodation expenses.
A Controversial Appointment Process
Normally, confirmation hearings are just a formality before an official appointment is made.
However, given the controversy surrounding Tuckett’s work arrangements, this case may be different.
His predecessor, David Neal, was dismissed last year after raising concerns about security lapses at London City Airport, adding further scrutiny to the appointment process.
Public records indicate that Tuckett previously owned a home near the scenic Saaksjärvi Lake in Finland between 2011 and 2013.
The area, located about 1,200 miles from Westminster, is known for its tranquil atmosphere and reputation as the “sauna capital of the world.”
Can Remote Leadership Work?
When asked directly by committee chair Dame Karen Bradley if he could commit to working from London full-time, Tuckett responded affirmatively, stating that he understands the need to be visible for ministers, site visits, and other key responsibilities.
However, he also reiterated the necessity of quiet, focused time for strategic work, which he believes can be done from anywhere.
While Home Office officials have stated that Tuckett’s working arrangements would be a personal decision, the debate over whether such an important role can be effectively managed remotely is far from settled.
As discussions continue, many are left wondering: Can a border watchdog really keep a close eye on immigration while working from abroad?
This article was published on TDPel Media. Thanks for reading!Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn