95-Year-Old Widow Faces £1 Million Legal Bill After Losing Decade-Long Battle Over Garden Fence

Malcolm Hemsworth
Published

A 95-year-old widow has been left responsible for more than £1 million in legal expenses after the High Court rejected her appeal in a long-running property dispute with her millionaire neighbours in Kent.

Mary Egan had challenged an earlier ruling that required both sides to cover their own legal costs, arguing that the conduct of businessman Neil Morgan, 65, and his wife Fiona, 61, had made the litigation unnecessarily expensive.

However, Mr Justice Tappin dismissed her appeal, upholding the original decision that the outcome of the dispute did not justify ordering the couple to pay her legal fees.

Disagreement Began Over Fence Between Neighbouring Properties

The dispute dates back to 2015, when the Morgans installed a replacement fence between their property, the 17th-century Sissinghurst Court, and land belonging to Egan in the village of Sissinghurst, near Tunbridge Wells.

The couple said they had replaced an existing fence because it had fallen into disrepair and their dogs and cats were escaping.

Egan disputed the position of the new structure, claiming it extended onto her property. Her lawyers alleged that the Morgans had entered her land without permission, removed an existing wooden fence and installed new posts.

After Egan cut down a replacement fence, the couple erected another structure using concrete posts in January 2016.

The disagreement subsequently developed into legal proceedings, with the Morgans suing Egan for damaging their fence. She responded with a counterclaim alleging trespass and asking the court to establish the boundary through the middle of a line of trees and hedges separating the properties.

Court Finds Trespass but Rejects Widow’s Boundary Claim

The case went to trial at Maidstone County Court in 2021, where Recorder John Dagnall dismissed the Morgans’ claim and found that they had trespassed on Egan’s land.

The judge awarded Egan £2,600 in damages. She received a further £3,250 after the court allowed the third fence to remain as the new boundary instead of ordering its removal.

However, the judge rejected her argument that the legal boundary should run through the middle of the hedge.

At a subsequent hearing in 2024, the judge described the overall outcome as a “score draw” and directed both parties to pay their own legal expenses.

The Morgans had accumulated a six-figure legal bill before largely representing themselves, while Egan had continued using lawyers throughout the proceedings. Her legal costs exceeded £1 million over more than a decade.

Widow’s Lawyers Cite Insults and Abusive Correspondence

Egan appealed the costs decision, with her barrister, Daniel Petrides, arguing that she had been the successful party and should recover her legal expenses.

He told the High Court that Mr Morgan had repeatedly directed personal insults at lawyers, judges and other professionals involved in the proceedings.

One junior lawyer was allegedly described as a “lying hypocritical devious arse of spectacular proportions”, while another was called a “conceited, sanctimonious, conniving hypocrite”.

A solicitor was also accused of “sheer stupidity” and referred to as “Mr I-qualified-last-week”.

The barrister said a deputy district judge, Swales, had been described as “an offensive, provocative and prejudiced man”.

In a subsequent letter, the judge was reportedly called “moronic and genuinely not fit to judge vegetables at a village fete”.

Petrides also cited correspondence in which his 95-year-old client was described as “patronising”, “arrogant”, “malevolent” and “frankly poisonous”.

He argued that the language and conduct had increased the costs of the proceedings and should have influenced the original decision about who was responsible for paying them.

Barrister Says Widow Was the Clear Winner

Petrides challenged the description of the case as a draw, pointing out that Egan had successfully defended the Morgans’ claim and won damages after the court found trespass.

He argued that she should therefore have been recognised as the successful party.

“The only correct analysis can be that a party which has defeated a claim against it and succeeded on its counterclaim is the ‘successful party’. It is not a ‘score draw’, it is a 4-0 win,” he said.

The barrister added that Egan had not chosen to initiate the proceedings and had spent more than £1 million defending her property rights.

He argued that the scale of the legal expenses was partly attributable to what he described as the Morgans’ disproportionate approach to the litigation.

Petrides also said the court should use its costs powers to discourage personal attacks against junior lawyers and other legal professionals.

Neil Morgan Says Dispute Was About Ownership of Trees and Hedge

Mr Morgan represented himself and his wife during the appeal and disputed the suggestion that their conduct should make them responsible for Egan’s legal bill.

He said the couple had been provoked into responding and argued that only a small number of his remarks were being highlighted.

“Most of the time we bit our lip,” he said.

“The few occasions when I responded pithily are now being used.”

Morgan maintained that the central issue had always been the ownership and position of the trees and hedge separating the properties, rather than the damages awarded to Egan.

He said the boundary question accounted for approximately 95% of the dispute and argued that the widow had not achieved the outcome she wanted.

“She didn’t litigate for £5,000 worth of damages – not for 10 years. She didn’t get the rewards she was looking for. A small amount of damages doesn’t bear a conversion into a victory. This wasn’t about money. It never was,” he said.

Morgan also maintained that the couple had installed the fence where they believed the boundary had always been, explaining that the previous structure had fallen down and their pets were escaping.

He argued that he and his wife were the successful party because Egan had failed to establish that the boundary ran through the hedge.

High Court Upholds Original Legal Costs Decision

Dismissing the appeal, Mr Justice Tappin acknowledged that Morgan’s language towards lawyers and court officials had been unacceptable.

However, the judge ruled that the original court had been entitled to conclude that the conduct did not justify ordering the Morgans to pay Egan’s legal expenses.

The decision leaves the 95-year-old widow responsible for the legal costs accumulated during the decade-long dispute, which have exceeded £1 million.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Malcolm Hemsworth profile photo

About Malcolm Hemsworth