Wisconsin Husband Charged With Wife’s Murder Two Years After Claiming She Died in Laundry Accident

Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo
Published

A Wisconsin man who allegedly told police his wife died after falling down the stairs while doing laundry has been arrested and charged with her murder, following a two-year investigation that uncovered evidence of an alleged affair, suspicious internet searches and deleted text messages.

Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was taken into custody on Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in connection with the death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, 40.

Erica was found critically injured at the couple’s home in West Allis, Wisconsin, on October 13, 2024.

She was taken to hospital but was pronounced dead at 5.14am the following day.

Her death was initially presented as an accident by her husband, who claimed the couple had fallen down the stairs while he was attempting to carry her after she collapsed in their basement.

Carpenter’s Account of the Fatal Incident

According to the criminal complaint, emergency responders were called to the family home after receiving reports that a woman had fallen and was bleeding from the head.

When officers arrived, they found Carpenter performing CPR on his wife.

Erica was reportedly bleeding from her head, and her face had turned noticeably blue.

Carpenter allegedly told investigators that Erica had been feeling unwell throughout the day and had spent much of her time sleeping.

He claimed they had been doing laundry together in the basement when she suddenly collapsed and struck her head against the carpeted floor.

He further alleged that the incident was so loud that it woke their son, who was sleeping upstairs.

Rather than immediately calling emergency services, Carpenter reportedly attempted to carry his unconscious wife up the stairs.

He claimed he slipped during the attempt, causing both of them to fall down the staircase, with Erica hitting her head against a cinder block wall.

Investigation Uncovers Alleged Affair

Investigators began examining Carpenter’s personal life after a witness contacted police on October 22, 2024, and reported that a woman identified as AMV had been involved in an affair with him.

According to the witness, AMV believed Carpenter was preparing to divorce Erica and had allegedly been promised that he would ask his wife for a divorce during the weekend she died.

Another individual, who had known Carpenter since high school and trained in mixed martial arts with him, also reportedly told police that Carpenter had admitted to the affair.

During a December 2024 interview, Carpenter allegedly acknowledged the relationship but claimed AMV had refused to date him until he was divorced.

Investigators were also told that Carpenter had spent a night at the woman’s home just days after his wife’s death and had discussed introducing her to his son.

At a fundraising pub crawl organised in Erica’s memory approximately one month after her death, surveillance footage allegedly showed Carpenter and AMV behaving like a couple.

Life Insurance Payments Raised Further Questions

The investigation also revealed that Carpenter had received between $220,000 and $230,000 from his late wife’s life insurance policy.

A separate joint insurance policy worth $350,000 had not been paid out at the time of the investigation, according to the criminal complaint.

Police continued examining the couple’s relationship and the circumstances surrounding Erica’s death as additional evidence emerged.

Google Searches Made Before and After Her Death

Among the most significant discoveries were internet searches allegedly made by Carpenter in the weeks surrounding his wife’s death.

Investigators found that in September 2024, less than a month before Erica died, he had searched Google for the phrase, “Watching someone you love die.”

On October 13, 2024, the day Erica was found injured, he allegedly searched for information on whether pills could be crushed and taken in water.

A subsequent search on November 6 led investigators to a Facebook image containing the statement: “The hardest thing in the world is watching someone you love slowly die right in front of you.”

These discoveries became part of the evidence examined by detectives during the investigation.

Deleted Messages Revealed Wife’s Concerns About Her Drinking Water

Police also recovered deleted text messages from Carpenter’s phones, despite his earlier claim that he had not removed any information from the devices.

Investigators had obtained permission to search his three mobile phones after questioning him about his marriage.

He provided the passcodes and allegedly denied deleting anything within the preceding 24 hours.

However, messages exchanged between the couple on September 18, 2024, raised further concerns.

In one message, Erica reportedly confronted her husband about an unusual substance she had noticed in her drinking water.

She allegedly asked what he had been putting in her water over the preceding days, adding that she had noticed a powdery substance in it on at least two occasions.

Carpenter reportedly responded that he had been adding Liquid I.V. to the water for himself and insisted it was his drink.

Autopsy Reveals Medication and Possible Signs of Asphyxia

The medical examination of Erica’s body raised additional questions about the circumstances of her death.

Toxicology results showed that she had hydrocodone in her system, despite having no prescription for the medication.

Investigators said the substance’s presence could not be ruled out as a possible contributing factor in her death.

Her system also contained insomnia medication.

Although her cause of death was ultimately classified as undetermined, the deputy chief medical examiner identified blunt-force injuries to her neck and petechial haemorrhaging, findings that can be associated with asphyxia.

The medical examiner also questioned Carpenter about how he had allegedly been holding Erica during their reported fall down the stairs.

According to the complaint, his explanation did not account for why her heart had stopped beating.

Another Woman Allegedly Accused Carpenter of Strangulation

The investigation uncovered another incident involving AMV several months after Erica’s death.

In May 2025, police were reportedly called to the Carpenter family home after AMV accused Benjamin of putting his hand around her neck and strangling her.

She allegedly told an Uber driver who arrived to collect her that Carpenter would be responsible if she died.

She also reportedly showed the driver his contact information on her phone.

Son Recalls Hearing Scream Before Fatal Incident

In October 2025, investigators interviewed the couple’s son as part of their continuing investigation.

The boy reportedly recalled hearing a scream followed by a loud thud on the night his mother died.

He also told police that his father removed photographs of Erica from the family home approximately four weeks after her death.

AMV reportedly moved into the property two or three months later.

Erica’s Parents Speak Out After Husband’s Arrest

Erica’s parents, Debra and Michael Clarenbach, said the arrest and the revelations from the investigation had reopened the grief they had experienced since losing their only child.

They said they had gradually begun coming to terms with her death before learning about the allegations against her husband.

“Erica was one of a kind,” Debra said.

Michael described the latest developments as another painful experience for the family, saying they had felt as though their wounds were beginning to heal before the new revelations brought everything back.

He also said the investigation had completely changed their perception of Carpenter.

“Completely blindsided,” he said, adding that it appeared Carpenter had a dark side they had never known about.

Carpenter is being held without bond at Milwaukee County Jail.

He was scheduled to make his initial court appearance on Wednesday.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo profile photo

About Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo

A performance driven and goal oriented young lady with excellent verbal and non-verbal communication skills. She is experienced in creative writing, editing, proofreading, and administration. Oluwasewa Badewo is also skilled in Customer Service and Relationship Management, Project Management, Human Resource Management, Team work, and Leadership with a Master's degree in Communication and Language Arts (Applied Communication).