Coroner’s Report Turns Bullying Case Upside Down as Teen Who Fell to His Death Was Accused of Starting School Fight

Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo
Published

A 17-year-old student who died after falling from a fourth-floor balcony at a Los Angeles high school had allegedly attacked a male classmate and attempted to forcibly kiss a female student shortly before his death, according to a newly released medical examiner’s report.

Xavier Nungaray-Martinez died on September 30 after jumping from the fourth-floor balcony of Benjamin Franklin High School in Los Angeles.

A report released by the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner on Tuesday classified his death as suicide, stating that the cause was blunt traumatic injuries to his head and torso.

Report Details Events Before Fatal Fall

According to the report, Nungaray-Martinez initiated the confrontation by punching another male student before attempting to forcibly kiss a female classmate.

The girl reportedly pushed him away, after which an altercation broke out between the teenager and the male student.

Video footage captured shortly before his death showed Nungaray-Martinez being beaten by the other student before leaving the area and going over the balcony railing.

A substitute teacher reportedly intervened and separated the two boys.

However, Nungaray-Martinez ran down the hallway towards the railing and jumped, according to the medical examiner’s findings.

Witnesses also told investigators that the teenager appeared to be behaving as though he was under the influence of an unidentified substance before the confrontation.

Toxicology Report Detects Marijuana

The medical examiner’s toxicology findings recorded a presumed positive result for marijuana in Nungaray-Martinez’s system. No other substances were detected.

His family has denied allegations that he used drugs.

However, the findings do not establish whether the teenager was under the influence of cannabis when he died, as traces of the substance can remain detectable for weeks after consumption.

The report also documented a history of depression, citing information obtained from an investigator with the medical examiner’s office and a Los Angeles Police Department detective.

A family member whose identity was withheld in the report disputed the suggestion that he had been depressed, telling investigators that he had never received such a diagnosis.

The relative said Nungaray-Martinez had been performing well academically, receiving good grades, and appeared to be living a normal life.

Family Rejects Medical Examiner’s Conclusion

Nungaray-Martinez’s family has challenged the medical examiner’s conclusion that he died by suicide.

In a statement to NBC 4, relatives described the determination as completely unsupported and questioned the evidence and witness accounts considered during the investigation.

They also raised concerns about whether investigators properly distinguished between injuries to his head and brain.

The family maintained that the confrontation involving the teenager and another male student before his death required further examination.

His mother, Lilia Paola Nungaray, has previously alleged that her son endured repeated bullying and physical attacks during his time at Benjamin Franklin High School.

According to the family’s attorney, the teenager was repeatedly targeted and assaulted by a group of students during his sophomore year.

Parents File Lawsuits Against School District

The teenager’s parents have initiated legal action against the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD), accusing the district and school administrators of negligence and failing to protect their son.

His mother filed a complaint against the district on October 15, alleging that the fatal incident occurred as students were leaving for lunch.

According to her complaint, another student punched Nungaray-Martinez in the face, knocked him to the ground and continued striking him while he was down.

The filing cited an account from a classmate who allegedly witnessed the incident and claimed that Nungaray-Martinez did not fight back.

His mother further alleged that the supervising teacher failed to intervene immediately to separate the students and did not take sufficient steps to protect her son from further harm.

The complaint argued that the blows to his head, together with the fear and confusion caused by the alleged assault, left him disoriented before he went over the balcony railing.

Father’s Lawsuit Accuses School Officials of Failing to Act

A separate lawsuit filed by his father, William Amaya, on Friday accused school administrators of knowing that Nungaray-Martinez had previously experienced bullying but failing to take action.

The lawsuit alleged that the school district did not protect him from the student involved in the confrontation or other alleged bullies.

It also claimed that the beating prompted the teenager to flee in an apparent attempt to escape further violence, resulting in his fatal fall.

Both legal actions accuse LAUSD of negligence, allowing unsafe conditions on school grounds and failing to fulfil its responsibilities towards students.

The family is seeking unspecified damages.

Police Say There Was No Evidence of Foul Play

The Los Angeles Police Department stated last month that investigators had found no evidence of foul play in connection with the teenager’s death.

No arrests have been made in the case.

Following his death, hundreds of relatives, friends and fellow students gathered at a memorial near the school, leaving flowers and candles in his memory.

School District Responds to Legal Action

A spokesperson for the Los Angeles Unified School District expressed sympathy for Nungaray-Martinez’s family and the wider school community.

The district said every student deserved to feel safe, supported and respected in school.

It added that LAUSD remained committed to providing a safe and nurturing learning environment while supporting students’ well-being.

The spokesperson declined to comment specifically on the pending or potential litigation but said the district took concerns about student safety seriously.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo profile photo

About Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo

A performance driven and goal oriented young lady with excellent verbal and non-verbal communication skills. She is experienced in creative writing, editing, proofreading, and administration. Oluwasewa Badewo is also skilled in Customer Service and Relationship Management, Project Management, Human Resource Management, Team work, and Leadership with a Master's degree in Communication and Language Arts (Applied Communication).