Taylor Swift Threatens Countersuit Against Las Vegas Showgirl as Explosive Emails Expose Bitter Legal War

Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo
Published

Taylor Swift’s legal team has threatened to pursue counterclaims against Las Vegas performer Maren Flagg as their increasingly bitter trademark dispute over the title of the singer’s latest album, The Life of a Showgirl, intensifies.

In a new court filing, the pop star’s lawyers warned that certain defendants would consider filing counterclaims if any part of Flagg’s lawsuit survives.

They also described the performer’s request to question Swift under oath for up to three hours as unnecessarily burdensome and potentially harassing.

The latest development comes as both sides continue to exchange accusations over the use of the phrase ‘showgirl’ and whether Swift’s business activities in California could expose her to legal proceedings in the state.

Maren Flagg Claims Ownership of Showgirl Trademark

Flagg, who performs professionally as Maren Wade, filed her lawsuit in March against Swift, her company TAS Rights Management, Universal Music and merchandise company Bravado.

She alleges that the title of Swift’s 2025 album is confusingly similar to her registered trademark, Confessions of a Showgirl, which she says she has spent years developing.

Flagg began using the phrase in 2014 for a column in Las Vegas Weekly before registering it as a trademark in 2015. She subsequently used the name for a cabaret production, a book and a podcast.

The performer is seeking financial damages and an order preventing Swift and her business partners from marketing merchandise bearing the disputed album title.

Swift’s legal representatives have rejected the allegations, arguing that consumers would not confuse the internationally recognised singer with Flagg, whose performances take place in smaller venues, including golf resorts and recreational vehicle communities.

Swift’s Surprise Performance Becomes New Evidence

Flagg’s legal team has now challenged one of the arguments previously presented by Swift’s lawyers, who had repeatedly distinguished the singer’s musical performances from Flagg’s cabaret shows.

In a May 6 court filing opposing Flagg’s request for a preliminary injunction, Swift’s lawyers stated that none of the songs from The Life of a Showgirl had been performed live.

They also argued that Swift’s concerts historically took place in sold-out stadiums rather than smaller cabaret-style venues or golf resorts.

A similar argument appeared in a June motion seeking to have the lawsuit dismissed, with her lawyers maintaining that Swift had never offered a live performance connected to the album.

However, Swift performed The Fate of Ophelia, the album’s lead single, at the Academy Museum of Motion Pictures Gala in Los Angeles on October 17.

Introducing the song, she told the audience it was being performed for them for the first time.

The appearance marked her first performance with her band since the conclusion of the Eras Tour in December 2024.

In a court motion filed on October 29, Flagg’s attorney, Jaymie Parkkinen, argued that the performance had changed the circumstances surrounding the earlier claims.

“That statement is no longer true, and this Motion corrects the record,” Parkkinen wrote.

Flagg’s trademark registration covers live stage performances involving music, singing, dancing, comedy and drama, making the distinction relevant to her infringement allegations.

Instagram Post Raises Questions About Swift’s California Business Activities

Flagg’s lawyers also relied on Swift’s social media activity following the Academy Museum Gala performance.

Three days after the event, the singer shared photographs from the evening on Instagram, describing it as an unforgettable night and celebrating her return to performing with her band.

Her post credited two Los Angeles-based photographers, Getty Images and TAS Rights Management, the intellectual property company also named in the lawsuit.

Parkkinen argued that the company’s inclusion in the credits was significant to the dispute.

Swift and TAS Rights Management have maintained that California courts do not have jurisdiction over them because both are based in Tennessee.

In a sworn declaration submitted in June, a vice president of TAS Rights Management stated that the company did not control Swift’s appearances in California or elsewhere and did not commission merchandise photography sessions.

Flagg’s legal team disputes that explanation, arguing that the lawsuit concerns the company’s alleged involvement in commissioning photography and controlling coverage of Swift’s appearances in California, rather than merchandise photoshoots alone.

They maintain that the Academy Museum performance and the associated credits demonstrate business activities in the state.

Beverly Hills Filming Permit Reveals Music Video’s Secret Codename

Another element of Flagg’s latest court submissions concerns the production of Swift’s Patient Zero music video.

The video was filmed at a Beverly Hills mansion on March 13, just 17 days before Flagg initiated her lawsuit.

A filming permit issued by the City of Beverly Hills and submitted as evidence identifies the production by the codename ‘Quarry’.

According to the document, the production involved approximately 90 people and was scheduled to run from 8am to 9pm.

The permit also recorded fees totalling $14,052.80, including payments for police and traffic control officers.

It contained warnings about complaints from local residents concerning extended filming hours, production trucks occupying neighbourhood streets and frequent activity around the filming location.

Although the permit does not identify Swift, Flagg’s lawyers say they matched images from the music video with photographs of the property from real estate listings.

They also referenced behind-the-scenes footage showing Swift at the location.

The legal team argues that the production, which was handled by a Los Angeles-based company, provides further evidence that Swift conducted business in California before the lawsuit was filed.

Swift premiered the Patient Zero video at the MTV Video Music Awards in Los Angeles in September. She also received the newly introduced Artist Director award at the ceremony.

Flagg’s lawyers have additionally cited Swift’s appearances at the iHeartRadio Music Awards and the MTV Video Music Awards as examples of her commercial activities in the state.

Swift’s legal team previously dismissed the suggestion that her appearance at the iHeartRadio event amounted to advertising, describing the argument as ridiculous.

Flagg’s Lawyer Rejects Accusations of Harassment

In a statement, Parkkinen defended the request to question Swift and challenged the singer’s position that she lacked sufficient connections to California for the case to proceed there.

“Taylor Swift decided to tell the Court that she doesn’t have enough of a connection to California to be sued here. That’s hard to square with the facts,” the lawyer said.

Parkkinen listed the singer’s activities in Los Angeles, including filming The Fate of Ophelia video, conducting merchandise photography at the Los Angeles Theatre, shooting Patient Zero in Beverly Hills and premiering the music video at an awards ceremony.

She also highlighted Swift’s October performance of music from The Life of a Showgirl in the city.

“Given all this, we’ve asked to depose her. That isn’t harassment. It’s what happens when you make arguments the facts don’t support,” Parkkinen added.

The lawyer also criticised the threatened counterclaims, saying Swift’s legal team had not specified the basis for them.

“Maren Wade is the one who has owned her trademark for more than a decade, and Ms Swift is the one the Trademark Office has rejected twice,” she said.

Parkkinen described the countersuit threat as an attempt to pressure her client rather than a substantive legal argument.

Private Emails Expose Tensions Between Legal Teams

Emails submitted as part of the court proceedings have revealed the increasingly strained relationship between the lawyers representing both sides.

Katherine Wright Morrone, a partner at Venable LLP, the firm representing Swift, challenged Flagg’s legal team’s reliance on the October performance.

Morrone argued that the appearance took place months after Flagg amended her lawsuit and should not be considered relevant to the earlier claims.

She also described the performance as conduct protected by the First Amendment, noting that Swift had not mentioned The Life of a Showgirl during the appearance.

In another exchange, Morrone accused Flagg’s lawyers of attempting to strong-arm Swift’s legal team and failing to negotiate in good faith.

When Parkkinen requested legal authority supporting one of Morrone’s arguments, the lawyer responded that she was unsure why the information was needed because her side was not accepting the proposal.

Parkkinen maintained that the case was already behind schedule and pressed for the evidence-gathering process to begin.

Swift’s lawyers refused to proceed with discovery and are now asking Judge Serena Murillo to suspend the process until she rules on their request to dismiss the lawsuit.

Swift Rejects Proposal to Narrow the Lawsuit

Before the latest escalation, Flagg had offered to temporarily suspend her claims against Swift and TAS Rights Management if the proceedings could continue against Universal Music and Bravado.

However, Swift’s legal representatives declined the proposal.

Flagg’s legal team had formally requested permission on October 9 to question Swift for up to three hours and a representative of TAS Rights Management for up to four hours.

The proposed depositions would focus on the defendants’ business activities and connections to California.

Swift’s threatened counterclaims also follow an earlier legal argument made by her representatives in May.

At the time, they alleged that Flagg’s use of Swift’s music and trademarks to promote her cabaret production amounted to actionable infringement.

Judge Delays Key Hearing Until February 2027

The legal battle has also experienced delays in court.

A hearing scheduled for October 7 concerning Swift’s request to dismiss the lawsuit did not take place as originally planned.

Judge Serena Murillo initially postponed the hearing until December.

However, an order issued on November 4 moved it again, with the hearing now scheduled for February 3, 2027.

Before then, the court is expected to hear arguments on December 9 concerning Flagg’s newly submitted evidence and Swift’s request to freeze discovery.

The proceedings will determine whether the lawsuit can continue in California and whether Flagg’s trademark claims will advance against the singer and the other defendants.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo profile photo

About Adeayo Oluwasewa Badewo

A performance driven and goal oriented young lady with excellent verbal and non-verbal communication skills. She is experienced in creative writing, editing, proofreading, and administration. Oluwasewa Badewo is also skilled in Customer Service and Relationship Management, Project Management, Human Resource Management, Team work, and Leadership with a Master's degree in Communication and Language Arts (Applied Communication).