‘Scorched Earth’: Ben Ainslie’s Explosive Claims Expose Bitter Power Struggle With Billionaire Jim Ratcliffe

Malcolm Hemsworth
Published

The breakdown of the relationship between billionaire Sir Jim Ratcliffe and four-time British Olympic champion Sir Ben Ainslie has culminated in a bitter legal dispute over a £180 million yacht built for the 2024 America’s Cup.

The case, which was settled this week, followed Ineos’ decision to withdraw financial backing for Ainslie’s sailing team while demanding control of its assets and intellectual property.

One of the most serious allegations to emerge from the proceedings concerned an incident at Turweston Aerodrome in Buckinghamshire, where Ainslie claimed he was effectively imprisoned inside a building.

According to court documents, Ineos representative Raymond Fellows arrived at the offices of Ainslie’s Athena Racing with two security contractors and attached a chain and padlock to the building’s external doors after being refused the keys by its owner.

Signs declaring “No Entry” were placed on the doors. Ainslie and his financial officer, Matt Robinson, eventually escaped through a fire exit.

Ineos denied falsely imprisoning Ainslie, saying Fellows had secured the building to prevent people from entering and did not know anyone was inside. The company also maintained that alternative exits were available.

Alleged ‘Scorched Earth’ Warning During Barcelona Meeting

The court dispute also brought attention to an alleged warning made during a heated meeting in Barcelona over the ownership of the America’s Cup boat.

Ainslie claimed that Rob Nevin, chairman of Ineos Sport and a Manchester United board member, told him: “We have a phrase at Ineos: scorched earth. It means that if you don’t give Jim what he wants, he will burn your house down, or words to that effect.”

Ineos did not entirely challenge Ainslie’s account of the exchange, but maintained that the remark had been intended figuratively.

Fellows had previously been employed by Ratcliffe to provide security assistance during protests at Ineos’ controversial fracking operations in Britain.

Court papers from an earlier case described his assessment of a small group of activists and the use of social media monitoring as part of security work.

Ratcliffe’s Management Style Under Scrutiny at Manchester United

The dispute has also drawn attention to Ratcliffe’s management approach and the influence he exercises over senior executives across his business interests.

Several sources have described an organisation shaped by strong authority, repeated corporate slogans and a culture in which employees are reluctant to challenge the billionaire.

Nevin, 68, is a long-standing associate of Ratcliffe and chairs Ineos Sport, the division responsible for the company’s investments across several sporting sectors.

He has reportedly told people he has encountered since arriving at Manchester United that he has completed at least 60 major transactions in the oil and gas industry.

Ratcliffe’s sporting strategy was built around the idea of expanding Ineos into multiple disciplines, following the model of Red Bull.

However, the company’s involvement in football and other sports has faced setbacks, including criticism of its management decisions at Manchester United and OGC Nice.

Ratcliffe appointed his brother Bob as chief executive of Nice, the second football club he acquired.

At United, he also placed considerable confidence in former Team Sky cycling chief Sir Dave Brailsford, whom he regarded as particularly well suited to overseeing the football operation.

Brailsford had relatively limited connections within football, with many of his contacts coming through appearances at sports business conferences.

One source said there had been insufficient emphasis on recruiting people with deep knowledge of the football industry.

Ineos Executives and United’s Leadership Decisions Questioned

Ratcliffe’s approach to running Manchester United has also attracted criticism from people familiar with the club’s operations.

After acquiring his stake, he reportedly demonstrated his London Marathon training stretches to some United players.

He also relied heavily on Brailsford’s involvement in the club’s restructuring.

Sources said Brailsford and other Ineos figures were enthusiastic about the appointment of Omar Berrada, who had previously worked as chief operating officer at Manchester City, as United’s chief executive.

The club’s leadership structure has continued to attract scrutiny, with some observers questioning whether its executives have the experience needed to manage an organisation of United’s size.

One source said the club needed a chief executive with significant industry experience, a sporting director with a record comparable to former Ajax chief executive Edwin van der Sar, and a senior figure capable of maintaining a strong relationship with supporters.

The source also cited former United captain Bryan Robson as an example of the type of prominent football figure who could provide a connection between the boardroom and fans.

The same source argued that United had lost experienced personnel without adequately replacing them, despite continuing to face expectations associated with its status as one of football’s biggest clubs.

Former commercial executive Victoria Timpson, who secured the club’s Snapdragon sponsorship agreement, was among those who departed.

Ratcliffe’s ‘Ask Jim’ Interview Reveals His Business Priorities

Ratcliffe’s management philosophy was also discussed during a 30-minute internal interview conducted this summer by Ineos director of corporate affairs Tom Crotty.

During the session, Ratcliffe spoke about his dissatisfaction with the British government’s management of North Sea oilfields and criticised sections of the British sports media.

He described attending the World Cup final between Spain and Argentina in July as a great experience, despite what he called complaints from the British press.

Asked how he relaxes, Ratcliffe mentioned visiting the golf driving range and fishing at his salmon farm in Iceland. United executives, including Berrada and representatives of the Glazer family, have also travelled there for meetings.

He repeated Ineos’ three preferred characteristics: “Grit, rigour, humour”.

Ratcliffe also emphasised the importance of completing work properly before making major decisions and using capital carefully.

Manchester United was not discussed during the interview.

Ineos Begins Scaling Back Its Sporting Investments

The breakdown with Ainslie forms part of a wider reduction in Ineos’ sporting commitments.

The company has put its European football clubs, OGC Nice and FC Lausanne-Sport, up for sale amid protests from supporters.

Its involvement in cycling has also been reduced. The team previously known as Ineos Grenadiers now has Danish technology company Netcompany as a co-sponsor.

Ineos has also faced legal disputes with the New Zealand All Blacks rugby team and Tottenham Hotspur after the company ended commercial agreements before their scheduled completion.

Both disputes were eventually resolved through confidential settlements.

The developments have raised questions about the future of Ratcliffe’s original plan to establish Ineos as a major force across several sports.

Ratcliffe’s Position at Manchester United Comes Under Pressure

Ratcliffe does not sit on Manchester United’s board, with Ineos co-founder John Reece and Nevin representing his interests.

Jean-Claude Blanc, a 63-year-old French executive with experience involving the Olympic Games, the Tour de France and Paris Saint-Germain, was also appointed to the board. He has since stepped down.

Blanc was recruited for his experience and standing in sport and business and was reportedly present during the Barcelona meeting at which the alleged “scorched earth” remark was made.

As United continues to restructure its football operation, some observers have called for Ratcliffe to reconsider his approach and acknowledge mistakes made under the current leadership.

The club has also been linked with Mauricio Pochettino as a potential figure in its efforts to improve its fortunes.

Ainslie and Ratcliffe End Partnership After Legal Settlement

Ainslie and Ratcliffe are no longer believed to be friends following the dispute over the America’s Cup campaign.

Before the alleged incident at Turweston Aerodrome, Ainslie had spoken about the differences between running a business and managing a sporting team.

He said sporting organisations depended on carefully balanced groups of people and required leaders to consider both financial efficiency and the welfare of those involved.

Under the terms of the settlement reached this week, Ainslie will retain the £180 million yacht built for the 2024 America’s Cup campaign, bringing the legal dispute between the former partners to an end.

Spread the News. Share on
Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn
Malcolm Hemsworth profile photo

About Malcolm Hemsworth