Urgent Need for Mental Health Care Reform Highlighted by Tragic Death of Young Woman at Private Hospital

Urgent Need for Mental Health Care Reform Highlighted by Tragic Death of Young Woman at Private Hospital

The devastating death of Amina Ismail, a 20-year-old described by her family as a ‘cherished daughter filled with kindness,’ has prompted urgent calls for reform in the mental health care system.

Amina’s death marks the fourth young woman to die at the Priory Group’s Cheadle Royal Hospital in Stockport, Greater Manchester, within the last two years.

Her story has brought to light serious concerns about the current state of mental health services, particularly within private hospitals.

The Inquest and Coroner’s Findings

During an inquest into Amina’s death, it was revealed that she had been kept in a secure facility 80 miles from her home for 13 months longer than necessary due to a shortage of beds in more suitable, lower-grade facilities closer to her family.

This prolonged stay in an inappropriate setting contributed to the deterioration of her mental health, culminating in her being found hanged in her room in September 2023.

Despite efforts to resuscitate her after she went into cardiac arrest, Amina could not be saved.

Assistant Coroner Andrew Bridgman, overseeing the inquest, issued a stern warning about the dire state of mental health care in the country, stating that “unless something is different, there are going to be more deaths.”

Bridgman announced his intention to issue a report highlighting the national crisis in mental health care provision, emphasizing the urgent need for systemic changes.

Family’s Heartbreaking Experience

Amina Ismail’s family shared their profound grief and frustration over the circumstances leading to her death.

Her father, Ahmed Ismail, spoke of the family’s struggle to get Amina closer to home and the sense of isolation she felt while being detained far from her loved ones. “The last year was a real struggle for Amina.

She was miles away from home and despite us visiting and supporting her as much as we could, we felt she was isolated,” he said.

The pain of losing Amina has been compounded by the belief that her death could have been prevented if she had received appropriate care.

A National Issue

Amina’s tragic death is not an isolated case.

The inquest highlighted a worrying pattern of failures within the Priory Group’s Cheadle Royal Hospital, where several young women have died under similar circumstances.

For instance, Lauren Bridges, a ‘straight-A student’ who dreamed of becoming a doctor or nurse, died after being detained at the same hospital for over five months.

Her prolonged stay, far from home, and subsequent death in February 2022 echo the systemic issues revealed in Amina’s case.

The inquest also noted the deaths of Beth Matthews, a mental health blogger who ingested a poisonous substance in March 2022, and Deseree Fitzpatrick, who choked on medication in January 2022.

These cases, alongside Amina’s, underscore the critical need for improvements in mental health care, particularly in the private sector.

Calls for Reform

The coroner’s findings have intensified calls for reform within the mental health care system. Alexander Terry, a public law and human rights lawyer representing Amina’s family, criticized the heavy reliance on private sector facilities for mental health care.

“Amina’s story is yet another tragedy involving a young woman with complex mental health needs losing her life while detained miles from her home and her family,” he stated, highlighting the national shortage of appropriate rehabilitation placements.

The government had previously pledged to end out-of-area hospital placements by 2021, but this goal has not been met.

The continued failure to provide adequate care close to home for vulnerable individuals like Amina reflects systemic shortcomings that need urgent addressing.

Government Response

In response to the coroner’s report, a spokesperson for the Department of Health and Social Care expressed condolences to Amina’s family and reiterated the government’s commitment to improving mental health services.

The government has increased investment in mental health by £4.7 billion since 2018/19 and aims to expand the mental health workforce significantly.

However, as the inquest has shown, more needs to be done to ensure that vulnerable individuals receive the care they need in appropriate settings.


Amina Ismail’s tragic death and the coroner’s subsequent findings serve as a stark reminder of the critical flaws in the current mental health care system.

The systemic issues highlighted by her case and others like hers underscore the urgent need for comprehensive reform to prevent further tragedies.

Ensuring that individuals receive appropriate care close to their homes and improving the quality of mental health services are essential steps toward safeguarding the well-being of the most vulnerable in society.

TDPel Media

This article was published on TDPel Media. Thanks for reading!

Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn

Advertisement: Download Vital Signs App (VS App)