Trader Joe’s fans, rejoice! The grocery chain known for its quirky creations and cult-favorite snacks has quietly reintroduced two classic dessert cups that disappeared from shelves four years ago: Chocolate Pudding and Rice Pudding.
This isn’t one of their eccentric experiments like Chocolate Hummus or Peanuts in a Pickle—this is a straightforward, tried-and-true favorite that shoppers have been begging to see return.
Sweet Treats Made Simple
According to Trader Joe’s, the chocolate pudding is made by a supplier who specializes in rich, creamy desserts.
“Remarkably elegant, with a super smooth and silky texture,” the chain says.
Both puddings come in four-packs priced at just $2.99, making them an easy pick for after-dinner indulgence or a lunchbox treat.
The store even suggested a nostalgic twist for kids: top the pudding with gummy worms and crushed Joe-Joe cookies for a playful “worms in dirt” dessert.
Fans Celebrate the Return
The announcement has sparked a wave of excitement online.
On Reddit, longtime fans shared their joy:
“A few years ago I was heartbroken,” wrote one.
“I might cry happy tears if it tastes the same.”
Others chimed in with similar enthusiasm: “I HAVE MISSED THEIR PUDDINGS!!!! This is great news.”
Many shoppers expressed delight at tasting the revival.
“Oh man, I think they’re both absolutely delicious. The rice pudding seems a little less creamy but I’m so happy they are back,” one user posted.
Some Critics Aren’t Convinced
Not everyone was entirely thrilled. Some fans felt the new versions didn’t live up to the originals:
“This lacks depth of chocolate flavor, it’s too sweet, and the texture is not right,” one reviewer said.
“It’s nowhere near the same,” added another.
Still, the majority of feedback has been overwhelmingly positive, showing just how passionate Trader Joe’s shoppers are about their favorites.
Customer Choice Awards and Other Fan Favorites
Earlier this year, Trader Joe’s revived its Customer Choice Awards, letting shoppers vote for their favorite products across 11 categories.
The top product for the third year in a row? Chili & Lime Flavored Rolled Corn Tortilla Chips, described as “spicy, ire-zest-tible little scrolls made from stone ground corn masa.”
The awards showcase just how dedicated the chain’s fanbase is, and how certain items achieve legendary status among customers.
Viral Success With Tote Bags
Trader Joe’s has also been making headlines for its viral mini tote bags.
Released initially in February and reintroduced in September, these $3 colorful canvas bags have caused shopping frenzies, with lines stretching outside stores and hundreds of thousands of bags selling out within a week.
Insider Matt Sloan noted on the Trader Joe’s podcast: “We expected good sales, but not this level of demand—it was phenomenal.”
From nostalgic puddings to must-have tote bags, Trader Joe’s continues to blend comfort, creativity, and a little chaos, keeping fans coming back for more.
Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn