In an unexpected turn of events, a Washington DC wedding venue, White Magnolia, owned by Janet Henderson Cagley and Callie Richardson, has found itself at the center of controversy.
The venue, initially praised for its picturesque charm, is now facing harsh criticism from multiple TikTok users who claim that its design echoes the painful history of slave quarters.
Architectural Controversy Erupts
Washington DC, March 10, 2024 – A once-celebrated wedding venue is now under intense scrutiny as TikTok videos draw attention to its alleged architectural resemblance to 18th Century slave cabins.
The White Magnolia, owned by a mother-daughter duo, has come under fire for what critics describe as a design that romanticizes a dark period in American history.
TikTok Outcry: Wedding Planner Sparks Debate
The controversy was ignited by Andrew Roby, a Black army veteran and wedding planner, who took to TikTok to express his concerns about the venue’s design choices.
In a video that quickly went viral, Roby compared the cottages on the White Magnolia property to historical slave quarters, sparking a heated online debate.
Defensive Stance: Owners Respond to Allegations
Despite the initial backlash, the venue’s owners have defended their architectural choices, emphasizing that the cottages were built from the ground up in recent years and were not refurbished quarters.
However, the lack of clarity from White Magnolia has only fueled the controversy, with critics arguing that the venue should have been more transparent about its design inspiration.
Social Media Backlash: ‘Cosplay Plantation’ Accusations
Social media users have labeled White Magnolia a ‘cosplay plantation,’ pointing out details such as cotton plants used as décor.
The venue’s decision to disable comments on its social media posts has further intensified the debate, with many condemning the perceived lack of accountability.
Online Divide: Support and Skepticism
While some TikTok users expressed support for Roby’s claims, others countered that there were no substantial similarities and emphasized the importance of perception.
As the controversy unfolds, the venue’s reputation is hanging in the balance, with potential clients reconsidering bookings.