Viewers of The Traitors aren’t just enjoying the drama unfolding on screen — they’re actively hunting for hidden clues that could point to a major surprise.
With the BBC hit now deep into its fourth series, fans believe the show may be quietly setting up another jaw-dropping reveal involving one of the Faithful players.
Claudia Winkleman Returns as Secrets Continue to Pile Up
Claudia Winkleman is once again at the helm of the psychological game, guiding contestants through betrayals, alliances, and carefully planted twists.
Audiences already know about one secret mother-and-daughter pairing revealed to viewers, but many are convinced that’s only the beginning.
Online detectives think more concealed connections are waiting to be uncovered.
Why Viewers Think Ben Is Hiding Something Big
Reddit users recently zeroed in on contestant Ben, a 66-year-old retired Navy officer, after noticing something odd — his surname appears to be missing everywhere online.
While the show often limits how much personal information it releases, fans say this particular omission feels deliberate.
Ben, who became the second Faithful to be “murdered” by the Traitors, is listed only by his first name on official materials, fan wikis, and even in local newspaper interviews.
That detail alone raised eyebrows.
Reddit Sleuths Believe the Missing Surname Is a Major Clue
One fan confidently declared they’d uncovered the season’s “big twist,” pointing out that every other contestant has been identified by their full name.
According to them, even local newspapers — which normally insist on full names — referred to him simply as “Ben,” suggesting a specific agreement was in place.
The theory? Revealing his surname might make it too easy for viewers to uncover a connection to another contestant, possibly someone still in the game.
Fans Offer Competing Theories About Ben’s Background
Not everyone agrees on the reason behind the secrecy.
Some fans think Ben’s military background could explain the lack of detail.
Others believe the answer lies much closer to home.
One viewer noted a resemblance between Ben and fellow contestant James, especially around the eyes.
They also pointed out that James is from Weymouth, not far from Hampshire, where Ben has given interviews.
Add Ben’s Navy career — potentially linked to Portsmouth — and the pieces start to look suspiciously connected.
Former Contestant Fuels More Family Connection Speculation
The guessing doesn’t stop with Ben.
Former contestant Judy Wilson, a 60-year-old child liaison officer, has added fuel to the fire by suggesting other hidden relationships may exist in the castle.
Judy, who was the first player voted out despite being a Faithful, knows a thing or two about secret ties.
She successfully hid her real-life connection to her adopted daughter, Roxy, while in the game.
Maz and Faraaz Spark Father-Son Rumours
Speaking openly after her exit, Judy revealed that players frequently speculated about a possible father-son link between 59-year-old Maz and 22-year-old Faraaz.
According to her, the theory came up repeatedly during filming, with many contestants convinced there was something more than friendship between them.
Fans watching at home picked up on the same vibe, with Reddit posts questioning whether the pair could be related.
One Viewer Shuts Down the Theory — With Confidence
Just as the speculation gained momentum, one Reddit user stepped in to dismiss the idea entirely.
Claiming personal knowledge of Faraaz, they stated outright that Maz is not his father and added that they’ve met Faraaz’s real dad.
That revelation cooled the theory — at least for now.
More Mysteries Ahead as the Game Continues
With secrets already exposed and others still under wraps, fans are convinced The Traitors has more surprises waiting.
Whether Ben’s missing surname leads to a shocking family reveal or turns out to be a clever red herring, viewers will be watching every detail closely.
The Traitors airs Wednesday nights on BBC One and is available to stream on iPlayer.
The big question remains — what twist will be uncovered next?
Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn