The ‘Scone’ Pronunciation Debate – A Linguistic Perspective and Regional Variances

Decades-Long Pronunciation Debate:

The pronunciation of the word ‘scone’ has been a source of debate among generations of Brits for years, with conflicting opinions on whether it should rhyme with ‘gone’ or ‘phone.’

Susie Dent, known for her role on Channel 4’s Countdown, sheds light on this linguistic puzzle.

Susie Dent’s Insights and Audience Reactions:

Susie Dent, reflecting on her experiences touring with her stage show The Secret Lives of Words, reveals that the question of how to pronounce ‘scone’ was consistently asked by audiences.

Dent notes that both pronunciations, rhyming with ‘phone’ or ‘gone,’ are deemed correct according to the dictionary.

Regional Variations and Dictionary Pronunciation:

The Cambridge Dictionary specifies that in the UK, ‘scone’ is pronounced as ‘skon,’ while in the United States, it should be said as ‘skown.’

Regional variations in the UK are highlighted by Cambridge University researchers, who created The Great Scone Map.

The ‘phone’ pronunciation is prevalent in the English Midlands and southern Ireland, while the ‘gone’ pronunciation dominates in the North of England, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.

Jam or Cream First – The Devon vs. Cornwall Debate:

Susie Dent does not delve into the classic debate of whether jam or cream should be spread first on a scone.

This ongoing disagreement has divided Devon and Cornwall for years.

The ‘Devon method’ involves spreading clotted cream first, followed by jam, while the ‘Cornish method’ reverses the order.

Royal Preference and Culinary Traditions:

Scones hold a special place in culinary traditions, especially at Buckingham Palace, where fruit scones are traditionally served every summer.

Former royal chef Darren McGrady reveals that the Queen reportedly opts for the ‘jam first’ approach during Buckingham Palace garden parties, with homemade Balmoral jam preceding clotted cream.

Conclusion – A Tasty Debate Continues:

The scone pronunciation debate, a fixture in British culture, showcases linguistic diversity and regional nuances.

Whether one prefers the ‘phone’ or ‘gone’ pronunciation, and the order of jam and cream, adds a flavorful dimension to this culinary and linguistic discussion.

Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn