National Highways missed ten opportunities over a 12-month period to investigate and address faults affecting 154 speed cameras across England, according to a report examining the handling of the issue.
The defective cameras cover approximately 440 miles of major roads, including smart motorways, and have been out of action since December 2025. The affected stretch represents roughly one in every ten miles of England’s Strategic Road Network, which includes motorways and major A-roads.
The report found that the agency had received warnings about the problem but repeatedly failed to take appropriate action. Police first raised concerns in January 2025, but the public was not informed until December that year.
The failures potentially resulted in thousands of motorists receiving speeding penalties they should not have received.
Police Warning Followed Incorrect M5 Speeding Ticket
The issue was first brought to National Highways’ attention in January 2025 by Avon and Somerset Constabulary after a motorist presented dashcam footage showing an apparent error on the M5.
The footage showed an overhead gantry displaying a 50mph speed limit, while the driver had received a speeding ticket for exceeding a 40mph limit.
National Highways did not immediately launch an investigation, instead treating the incident as isolated. The report said that conclusion was not supported by demonstrable data analysis or other substantial evidence.
In March 2025, Road Safety Support, a specialist not-for-profit organisation, warned that the problem was unlikely to be an isolated case. It also indicated that the matter should probably be escalated to the police and National Highways’ legal services.
However, the warning was not acted upon as recommended.
Investigation Delayed Despite Further Warnings
A formal investigation team was not established until August 2025, approximately ten weeks after the process of assembling it began.
By that stage, National Highways had an emerging understanding of the potential consequences, including the risk of motorists being wrongly prosecuted and damage to the agency’s reputation.
Despite this, the report found that National Highways did not activate its Crisis Management Manual, identifying this as another missed opportunity to respond appropriately.
By the end of September 2025, the underlying cause of the faults had still not been fully recognised, although it had become apparent that the problem affected a wider network of cameras.
The report also found that the National Police Chiefs’ Council should have received a full briefing earlier. National Highways did not notify the 22 relevant police forces until November 2025.
The agency eventually informed the public in December, bringing the total number of missed opportunities identified by the report to ten.
Faults Linked to Interaction Between Cameras and Speed Signs
The report identified problems involving the way speed cameras interacted with variable speed-limit signs displayed on overhead gantries.
It said National Highways should have identified these faults during the specification and testing stages before 2025.
According to the findings, many of the problems that emerged later resulted from the failure to identify the defects at that earlier stage.
The issue has particular implications for smart motorways, where speed limits can change to manage traffic and reduce the risk of collisions and injuries. Accurate enforcement is an important part of the system.
The affected cameras have remained out of operation since December 2025.
Thousands of Motorists May Have Received Incorrect Fines
Around 2,650 speeding tickets issued incorrectly since 2021 have been identified so far. However, the report indicates that the actual number of affected motorists could be significantly higher, with potentially thousands of additional cases.
The report was commissioned by Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander in January 2026, and ministers had received it in July before it was made public on November 18.
The timing of its publication prompted accusations from critics that the government was attempting to draw limited attention to the findings by releasing them while Westminster was focused on the Milburn report on youth unemployment.
Government Ends Contract With Camera Operator
Ministers announced that National Highways was ending its contract with Verra Mobility, the American company responsible for operating the 154 affected cameras.
The operator had originally been scheduled for replacement in 2028, but National Highways said the change would now be accelerated.
Roads Minister Justin Madders said in a written statement that safety remained the government’s overriding priority. He added that additional measures being introduced to strengthen enforcement arrangements would allow action to be taken against people who broke the law.
Political and Motoring Groups Criticise Response
Conservative shadow transport secretary Richard Holden criticised the delays, saying thousands of motorists had received fines despite doing nothing wrong.
He said the faults should have been addressed immediately after they were discovered and questioned why repeated warnings and missed opportunities were needed before action was taken.
Conservative shadow transport minister Greg Smith described the failures as unacceptable. He also criticised the government for delaying publication of a report detailing shortcomings at National Highways.
AA president Edmund King said the findings showed that the issue went beyond a technical problem, describing it as a failure to respond with the urgency expected by motorists.
He said drivers needed confidence that motorway technology was accurate, reliable and properly tested, particularly on smart motorways, adding that restoring public confidence and protecting lives were important.
The report’s findings come amid continuing concerns about smart motorway safety, including issues previously raised through a Daily Mail campaign highlighting deaths on the roads.