When a federal agency rushes to meet a big staffing target, mistakes can happen — but insiders say this time, things went completely off the rails.
What was supposed to be a major push to strengthen immigration enforcement instead turned into a costly mess, with taxpayer money flowing to recruits who struggled to pass even the most basic requirements.
New information shared by people inside the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) paints a picture of a recruitment campaign that ballooned too fast, skipped critical vetting, and ended up rewarding hundreds of unqualified applicants.
Unexpected Bonuses Going to the Wrong People
According to insiders, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) ended up paying out around $1.5 million in $10,000 signing bonuses — not to top-tier candidates, but to recruits who failed training, flunked open-book exams, or never should have been accepted at all.
The idea behind the bonus was simple: attract enough applicants to hit the Trump administration’s goal of hiring 10,000 new deportation officers by year’s end.
But the structure was so loosely designed that the first $10,000 was awarded just for showing up, regardless of whether recruits ultimately passed the academy.
One DHS official summed it up bluntly: “They didn’t link the bonus to actually qualifying for the job.
You show up, you ‘Enter on Duty,’ and you get paid. Pass or fail — it didn’t matter.”
Officials Realize the Mistake Too Late
It took months before the oversight was caught.
By then, an estimated 150 unfit recruits had already pocketed the bonus.
Officials questioned why so many poorly performing trainees arrived at the academy — only to later discover the cash incentive waiting for them on day one.
The situation grew so embarrassing that some employees described it as “idiotic” but admitted the agency had locked itself into the arrangement by announcing the bonus terms publicly.
Mass Failures at the Academy Add to the Crisis
The magnitude of the problem became even clearer when internal records revealed that 584 recruits had already failed out of training as of December 1.
Everything from academic shortcomings to physical unfitness contributed to the exodus.
Instructors reported trainees struggling through open-book tests and others who could “barely read or write English.”
One recruit weighed 469 pounds and had a medical note indicating he was unfit for any physical activity — yet still made it to the academy.
Another alarming issue: some new hires were flown out to Georgia for training before their drug test results were processed, only for several results to later come back positive.
DHS Scrambles to Reverse the Bonus Policy
Once DHS realized how much money had been handed out prematurely, the agency attempted a swift pivot.
A new notice went out in mid-November titled “Updated Incentive Payment Information.”
This memo clarified that bonuses would only be paid after recruits completed their initial training and passed the required firearms qualification.
For those who previously worked in law enforcement — and therefore didn’t need full academy training — the incentive would be delayed until at least 90 days after their official start date.
Even so, insiders say clawing back the bonuses already paid will be extremely difficult, given how vaguely the original announcement was written.
A Recruitment Strategy Widely Viewed as an Embarrassment
Current and former employees describe the broader hiring effort as a “national embarrassment.”
In their view, the pressure to hit the 10,000-officer benchmark led DHS to lower standards to levels they had never seen before.
Reports from inside the agency detail a flood of underqualified candidates:
- high school graduates with no experience
- retirees returning to desk jobs
- individuals with pending criminal cases
- physically unfit applicants
- people unable to meet basic literacy requirements
Many of the new hires, especially retirees, are being fast-tracked through virtual training and reassigned to administrative roles that don’t involve fieldwork.
Recruits Entering Training Without the Needed Skills
Officials working inside the academy say that despite the urgency, many of the new recruits will never be able to carry out the duties the agency needs.
Some former officers lack the experience required for immigration cases, while total beginners cannot complete even foundational tasks.
One DHS insider explained it this way: “They just want bodies showing up on paper so it looks like we’re hitting the goal.
Whether these people can actually work in the field is irrelevant to leadership.”
The result is a class of recruits who — even if they finish training — may never be fully operational.
The Push Toward 10,000 Officers Comes at a Steep Cost
DHS Secretary Kristi Noem has already informed President Trump that the department will reach its 10,000th hire by Friday.
But internally, sources insist that milestone comes only because standards were dramatically lowered to push through as many people as possible.
Many of the recruits won’t be ready for patrol teams, arrest operations, or field investigations. Some won’t even be equipped to process paperwork correctly.
In the eyes of those inside DHS, the current hiring strategy reflects a singular focus on quantity over quality, leaving the agency with a wave of recruits who may never be able to perform the jobs they were hired to do.
What Comes Next?
The biggest question now is whether DHS can stabilize an already chaotic process. Officials are still figuring out how to reclaim bonuses, repair broken vetting systems, and restore minimum standards at the academy.
With so many underprepared recruits in the pipeline — and pressure to meet political hiring goals — insiders fear the consequences of this rushed expansion will be felt for years.
Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn