The Caribbean is known for its breathtaking beauty, but with so many islands to choose from, it can be difficult to decide where to go.
With 31 islands and territories scattered across the region, visitors have an overwhelming number of options.
To help make your decision easier, Which? Travel polled 647 travelers to find out which Caribbean destinations stand out the most. After all, paradise can come in many forms.
From beautiful beaches to unique cultural experiences, here are the top picks for every kind of vacationer.
Best for Foodies and Overall Favorite – Grenada
Known as the Spice Island, Grenada has earned its place as the best overall Caribbean island.
Despite its relatively small size, Grenada is a powerhouse for food lovers, thanks to its fertile soils that produce nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, and ginger.
These spices are not just found in local dishes but have become part of the island’s identity.
Which? Travel also recommends the Belmont Estate, where visitors can tour cacao plantations and even make their own chocolate.
What makes Grenada stand out is its authenticity—there’s a refreshing lack of heavy tourism, allowing visitors to fully enjoy the natural beauty and flavors of the island.
Best for Beaches – Antigua and Barbuda
Antigua and Barbuda offer something every beach lover dreams of—stunning, pristine beaches.
According to Which? Travel, the islands claim to have a different beach for every day of the year, and Half Moon Bay is a must-visit.
If you’re into history, a stop at Nelson’s Dockyard is a must, as it was once one of the Royal Navy’s largest Caribbean bases.
For those seeking a quiet retreat, Barbuda is just a short flight away and offers birdwatching opportunities, making it a perfect day trip for nature lovers.
Best for Culture – Barbados
Barbados is a destination that offers a beautiful blend of culture and relaxation.
The island boasts not only beautiful beaches but also rich history, with beautifully preserved architecture in its capital, Bridgetown, which is listed by UNESCO.
For a truly cultural experience, head to Oistins on a Friday or Saturday for the famous fish fry, where locals gather for fresh seafood and entertainment.
And of course, no visit to Barbados is complete without enjoying a drink at a local rum shop—after all, Barbados is considered the birthplace of rum.
Best for Wildlife – Trinidad and Tobago
Trinidad and Tobago are a haven for wildlife enthusiasts, particularly birdwatchers.
The islands’ proximity to South America and diverse habitats, from rainforests to mangroves, create the perfect environment for spotting rare species.
While you’re out and about, hiking to stunning waterfalls or observing leatherback turtles laying their eggs is an unforgettable experience.
Even if you’re not into wildlife, there’s plenty to explore, from the beautiful beaches to the island’s rich cultural heritage.
Best for Music – Jamaica
If you’ve ever thought of the Caribbean and immediately heard reggae in your head, then you’re not alone.
Jamaica is the heart of Caribbean music, and the legacy of Bob Marley is felt everywhere.
Kingston, the capital, has become an arts hub, attracting visitors from around the world.
For those who prefer a quieter pace, the northern coast around Montego Bay offers peaceful resorts where you can unwind in paradise, all while soaking in the island’s musical heritage.
Best for Natural Scenery – St Lucia
St Lucia’s natural beauty is truly extraordinary. This island is home to dramatic landscapes, with lush mountains like the Pitons towering over the sea.
The island is also known for its sandy beaches that offer the perfect backdrop for a relaxing vacation.
Soufrière, located in the south, is the epicenter of tourism, and a trip to Sugar Beach, where the Pitons rise dramatically behind you, is a must-do.
Hiking the Gros Piton is another popular activity that promises breathtaking views.
Best for Whale Watching – Dominican Republic
For whale-watching enthusiasts, the Dominican Republic’s Peninsula de Samaná is a hidden gem.
From January to March, you can see humpback whales in their tropical breeding grounds, an experience that’s hard to beat.
But there’s more to this destination than just whales.
Visitors can also enjoy the island’s beaches, luxury resorts, and coffee plantations, offering a great mix of wildlife and relaxation.
Best Under-the-Radar Gem – Turks and Caicos Islands
Although not as widely known as some of the other Caribbean destinations, the Turks and Caicos Islands have a growing reputation for their beauty and tranquility.
With 40 islands and cays, the main island of Providenciales, or Provo as it’s often called, is home to the famous Grace Bay—an unspoiled 12-mile stretch of perfect beach.
Visitors here can enjoy snorkeling, vibrant coral reefs, and luxurious resorts.
For those who are willing to venture off the beaten path, the Turks and Caicos offer a slice of paradise without the crowds.
Conclusion: Which Caribbean Island Will You Visit?
The Caribbean offers something for every kind of traveler, whether you’re looking for cultural experiences, outdoor adventures, or just a beach to relax on.
From the food-centric delights of Grenada to the pristine beaches of Antigua and Barbuda, there’s no shortage of incredible destinations to explore.
So, what are you waiting for? Pack your bags and discover the paradise that awaits in the Caribbean.