When a tragic loss strikes a family, every decision around it feels heavier — especially when justice seems to hang in the balance.
That’s exactly what Jeffrey Metcalf, the father of a teenage football player who was fatally stabbed, is going through right now in Frisco, Texas.
He’s challenging a controversial move by Centennial High School that has left many people stunned and upset.
The Stabbing That Shocked a Community
On April 2nd, a horrific incident unfolded at a college track meet in Frisco.
Austin Metcalf, 17, was allegedly stabbed by Karmelo Anthony, 18, right there in the stadium.
Austin’s twin brother cradled him as he bled out — a moment no family should ever have to endure.
The incident rocked the community and sparked an intense debate, fueled further when some supporters of Anthony raised more than $500,000 to aid his defense.
The Diploma Controversy Ignites Anger
What has added fuel to the fire is the school’s decision to grant Anthony a high school diploma despite his alleged role in Austin’s death.
Jeffrey Metcalf has now filed a formal complaint with the Texas Education Agency (TEA), pushing back against Centennial High School’s move to let Anthony graduate.
Anthony’s spokesperson, Dominique Alexander, confirmed to DailyMail.com that Jeffrey had taken this step, explaining that it’s one of the few avenues available to contest the graduation.
While the practical implications of the complaint remain unclear, it clearly signals the father’s refusal to let this slide quietly.
School’s Reversal and House Arrest Restrictions
Initially, Frisco Independent School District aimed to expel Anthony, which would have stopped him from graduating altogether.
But just hours after a tense press conference last month, the school reversed course.
Though Anthony won’t be allowed to walk across the stage or attend the ceremony due to his house arrest status, the decision to let him graduate has left many baffled.
Alexander remarked, “They were literally trying to expel him — period.
Now we’re arranging for an early graduation, and they have agreed to allow him to graduate.”
The Aftermath of the Attack and Legal Proceedings
After the stabbing, Anthony fled the scene, leaving Austin to die in his brother’s arms.
He was quickly arrested and reportedly confessed with a simple “I did it.”
Since then, Anthony has attempted to argue self-defense in court.
Outrage erupted when Anthony’s bond was dramatically reduced from $1 million to $250,000, leading to his release.
At the bond hearing, Anthony’s father spoke about the family’s financial struggles, a point that clashed with reports exposing a $900,000 home the family rented in a gated community — raising questions about their true situation.
Neighbors React with Fear and Concern
The neighborhood surrounding the Anthony family’s rental home has been rattled by the entire ordeal.
Neighbors shared their fears with DailyMail.com, expressing disbelief and unease that Anthony could be living so close to them after the violent incident.
One neighbor said, “Not good. Not good. I don’t think he should be out.
Why would you stab someone? And now he’s a few doors down. It’s very scary.”
Another added that it would be best if the family moved away to ease community tensions.
Anthony Moves to a New, Secret Location
Facing backlash and concerned for his safety after his address was leaked online, Anthony reportedly left the gated community.
His current whereabouts remain undisclosed as the legal process continues and emotions run high in Frisco.