Defence Lawyers Oppose Witness’s Request for Broadcast Ban in Senzo Meyiwa Murder Trial

Defence Lawyers Oppose Witness’s Request for Broadcast Ban in Senzo Meyiwa Murder Trial

...By Joseph Benjamin for TDPel Media.

In the ongoing trial for the murder of soccer star Senzo Meyiwa, defence lawyers have objected to a request made by a State witness to impose a broadcast ban during her testimony.

Advertisement

The witness expressed concerns about her comfort and the potential impact on her career if her testimony is broadcasted live via audio or audiovisuals.

The defence lawyers argue that the request is unfounded and baseless, while the State prosecutor acknowledges the witness’s fears but suggests that journalists can be present in court to report on the proceedings without live broadcasting.

Witness’s Concerns and State Prosecutor’s Response

The witness, a public figure, conveyed her discomfort and apprehension regarding the live broadcast of her testimony.

She expressed fears of being ridiculed and criticized, particularly on social media, which she believes would unsettle her and hinder her from delivering her testimony effectively.

The State prosecutor, Advocate George Baloyi, acknowledged the witness’s concerns about her safety and the potential endangerment of her life if her evidence is perceived negatively by the public.

Also on TDPel Media:  Israeli Man Fatally Attacked in Dubai: Dispute Between Families Ends in Tragedy

Baloyi noted that the witness does not object to journalists being present in court and reporting on her testimony.

Advertisement

Defence Lawyers Oppose the Request

The defence lawyers representing the five accused individuals in the trial deemed the witness’s request as flimsy and lacking a solid basis.

Advocate Charles Mnisi, representing accused 3, expressed surprise at the witness’s demand, arguing that her face is already known to the public.

He asserted that she should not be treated differently from other witnesses who appeared in court.

Mnisi urged the court to proceed with the trial in the same manner as before.

Witness’s Media Involvement and Lack of Prejudice

Advocate Zandile Mshololo, representing one of the accused, pointed out that the witness is not unfamiliar with media attention.

Mshololo highlighted that the witness has been vocal about the case on social media and has given interviews related to the matter.

Also on TDPel Media:  Supreme Court Dismisses Suit against Bola Tinubu and Kashim Shettima as APC Candidates

Mshololo argued that there is no evidence to suggest that the witness has suffered prejudice by participating in the Netflix docuseries about Senzo Meyiwa.

Additionally, Mshololo mentioned that the witness has benefited financially from the documentary and has not previously requested limitations on the recording of her face.

Advertisement

Pending Ruling and Trial Resumption

The judge has yet to make a ruling on the witness’s request for a broadcast ban.

The State was expected to submit its heads of arguments on Monday, while the defence promised to file answering affidavits by Tuesday.

The trial is scheduled to resume on Wednesday, May 17.

Analysis:

While the witness expresses concerns about potential harm to her reputation and career, the defence argues that she should not receive special treatment, given her existing media involvement.

The State prosecutor acknowledges the witness’s worries but suggests an alternative solution that allows journalists to report on the proceedings without live broadcasting.

Also on TDPel Media:  SNL Brings Humor to Sweltering NYC Heat Wave with Parody of Central Park Culture

The pending ruling on the matter adds a layer of anticipation to the trial’s proceedings.

Advertisement

Read More On The Topic On TDPel Media

About the Author:

Joseph Benjamin is an experienced journalist with a successful career spanning over 18 years. He has made a name for himself in the industry through his insightful and engaging reporting, and his dedication to delivering accurate and unbiased news. Joseph's years of experience have equipped him with a keen understanding of the media landscape, and he has become a trusted voice in his field. His writing style is characterized by its clarity, precision, and attention to detail, making his articles a pleasure to read. Joseph is a dedicated professional who is committed to providing his readers with the most up-to-date and relevant news and information. He lives in Ontario, Canada.

Advertisement