The bizarre and tragic case involving professional cornhole player Dayton James Webber — a quadruple amputee turned sports personality — has taken an unexpected turn with fresh details emerging from his ex‑girlfriend’s account.
What was already a disturbing story has now raised more questions about his temperament, relationships, and the lead‑up to the fatal shooting of Bradrick Michael Wells in Charles County, Maryland.
Ex‑Girlfriend Speaks Out: A Troubled Past
Webber’s former partner, Tori Mattingly, says she dated him for four years before breaking things off in February 2025.
According to her, Webber had a history of anger issues and emotional volatility, something she says she witnessed firsthand during their relationship.
Mattingly also revealed something even more uncanny — after their split, she briefly dated the victim, Brad Wells, whom Webber is now accused of killing.
She insists there was no overlap in her relationships with the two men, and says neither relationship ended recently enough to have directly fueled the dispute, though she admits Webber knew about her later romance with Wells.
What Happened the Night of the Shooting
Official reports allege the fatal incident occurred late on March 22, 2026, when Webber and Wells were riding in a Tesla SUV in La Plata, Maryland.
After an argument between the two men, Webber allegedly shot Wells twice while driving.
According to investigators, Webber then stopped the vehicle and asked two passengers in the backseat to help remove Wells’ body — they refused and fled, later flagging down police.
Wells’ body was discovered later in a yard in Charlotte Hall, Maryland.
Webber was eventually located and arrested in Charlottesville, Virginia, at a hospital where he was receiving treatment for an unrelated medical issue.
The Background of an Unusual Athlete
Webber isn’t just any suspect — his story was once one of resilience and inspiration.
Born with severe bacterial infection, he underwent amputations of all four limbs as an infant but went on to become a trailblazer in the American Cornhole League, gaining national attention for his prowess and ability to defy expectations.
He embraced life and sport with an intensity that made him the first quadruple amputee professional cornhole player, and he was featured in motivational essays and televised sports highlights for his accomplishments.
A More Complex Narrative
The new details from Mattingly paint a far more complicated picture than initial reports suggested.
What once seemed like an isolated criminal act is now being given a layer of personal context: tangled relationships, long‑running behavioral concerns, and emotional upheaval that may or may not have contributed to the altercation described in police documents.
Impact and Consequences
This case touches on several important themes: mental health, the limits of inspirational narratives in media, and how personal dynamics can intertwine tragically with violence.
If the allegations in the murder charge hold true, Webber could face first‑degree murder, second‑degree murder, and firearm use charges when he returns to Maryland to stand trial.
Moreover, Webber’s fall from celebrated athlete to accused killer has already sparked debate across social media and news outlets about how society perceives and lionizes figures with extraordinary backstories, sometimes overlooking warning signs.
What’s Next?
Webber waived extradition and is expected to be transferred back to Maryland in the coming weeks to face formal charges, with his next court dates set in April.
Authorities are continuing to investigate the exact motive behind the fatal argument, and courtroom proceedings will likely unfold slowly — giving the public time to reassess what they thought they knew about the people involved.
Summary
- Dayton James Webber, a professional cornhole player and quadruple amputee, was arrested after allegedly shooting friend Bradrick Michael Wells in Maryland.
- His ex‑girlfriend, Tori Mattingly, revealed she had witnessed anger issues during their four‑year relationship and later briefly dated Wells.
- The shooting occurred during a car argument; Wells was found dead days later in Charlotte Hall, Maryland.
- Webber was found in Virginia and arrested before being extradited to Maryland.
- Webber’s athletic past includes trailblazing as the first quadruple amputee in professional cornhole.
Bulleted Takeaways
- Ex‑girlfriend says Webber showed a “dark, angry side” during their relationship.
- Mattingly dated the victim, Brad Wells, after splitting with Webber, but says there was no overlap.
- Police say Webber shot Wells during an argument in La Plata, Maryland.
- Webber had lived an inspirational life as a quadruple amputee sports figure before the alleged crime.
- The case raises questions about personal behavior, public image, and accountability amid sensational media coverage.
