…By Lola Smith for TDPel Media. An advocate acting for Judge Tintswalo Annah Nana Makhubele has argued that she did not directly or indirectly instruct anyone at the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (PRASA) to pay a settlement to corruption-accused company Siyaya.
Advertisement
This statement was made during the Judicial Conduct Tribunal, which was held to investigate allegations of misconduct against Makhubele during her time as PRASA’s interim board chairperson.
This tribunal was recommended three years ago by the Judicial Conduct Committee (JCC) after activist group #UniteBehind lodged a complaint against Makhubele with the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) in 2019.
Background:
When Makhubele was appointed as interim board chairperson in October 2017, the rail agency’s legal department had already received summonses from Siyaya and its subsidiary companies, including Siyaya DB Consulting Engineers for outstanding payments.
Contracts with Siyaya and its subsidiaries were the subject of a number of investigations.
PRASA’s suspended head of legal, risk and compliance, Martha Ngoye, previously told the tribunal that PRASA’s legal department and the responsible managers within PRASA’s business units had decided to defend the summonses and handed them over to Diale Mogashoa Attorneys, who had been appointed to act on behalf of the rail agency.
The tribunal:
During the tribunal, Ngoye claimed that Makhubele instructed all matters related to Siyaya to go through her first.
Advertisement
Ngoye also claimed that the decision to defend Siyaya’s summonses was then abandoned for a settlement, which occurred “without consulting” PRASA’s legal department.
In March 2018, Ngoye and her team learned that PRASA would be making a payment of about R56-million to Siyaya.
A public outcry prompted the Minister of Transport to permit a rescission of the settlement, leading Ngoye to successfully apply for an urgent interdict to stop the payment.
The Advocate’s Statement:
Acting for Makhubele, advocate Vincent Maleka rebutted Ngoye’s testimony that the R56-million settlement was paid under Makhubele’s instruction.
Maleka argued that documents before the tribunal showed no mention of such an instruction from Makhubele.
However, Ngoye refuted this under Maleka’s cross-examination, saying Makhubele was “instrumental in ensuring that the settlement happens” and was very involved in giving instructions about the settlement to former acting group CEOs Lindikhaya Zide and Cromet Molepo, and to Diale Mogashoa Attorneys.
Analysis and Commentaries:
This case shows the importance of conducting independent investigations into allegations of misconduct by public officials.
The fact that the tribunal is being held almost four years after #UniteBehind lodged a complaint against Makhubele highlights the need for timely investigations.
Advertisement
The conflicting statements between Ngoye and Makhubele’s advocate show that the truth may be difficult to ascertain in cases where there are no clear records of instructions or decisions.
Nonetheless, it is important that any allegations of misconduct be thoroughly investigated to maintain public confidence in the judiciary and public institutions.
About the Author:
Lola Smith is a highly experienced writer and journalist with over 25 years of experience in the field. Her special interest lies in journalistic writeups, where she can utilize her skills and knowledge to bring important stories to the public eye. Lola’s dedication to her craft is unparalleled, and she writes with passion and precision, ensuring that her articles are informative, engaging, and thought-provoking. She lives in New York, USA.
Share on Facebook «||»
Share on Twitter «||»
Share on Reddit «||»
Share on LinkedIn Read Related News On TDPel Media
Advertisement
Judge Approves $100 Million Settlement to British Tourist’s Family After Grand Canyon Helicopter Crash Tragedy: Judge Approves $100 Million Settlement In a significant legal development, a US judge has sanctioned a landmark $100 million cash settlement for the parents of...
Washington Trust to Pay $9 Million Settlement for Alleged Lending Discrimination in Rhode Island: Justice Department Secures $9 Million Settlement in Redlining Case Involving Washington Trust The Justice Department has announced a significant development in the fight against lending...
Ime Udoka to Pay Nia Long $32,500 Monthly in Child Support Following Custody Settlement: Child Support Settlement Details Ime Udoka, the head coach of the Houston Rockets, is set to pay actress Nia Long $32,500 monthly in child support,...
Disgraced Doctor’s Lawyer Argues Lack of Consent in Controversial Deportation Case: Advertisement Read More On The Topic On TDPel Media Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn Read...
Ariana Madix, actress of Vanderpump Rules, argues that she is still living with her ex-boyfriend Tom Sandoval in order to prevent “uprooting” her dog and aging cat: “I always keep my door locked.”: Advertisements Read More On The Topic On TDPel Media Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn Read...
Ariana Madix, actress of Vanderpump Rules, argues that she is still living with her ex-boyfriend Tom Sandoval in order to prevent “uprooting” her dog and aging cat: “I always keep my door locked.”: Ariana Madix, a star of Vanderpump Rules, has defended her decision to continue living with her ex-boyfriend Tom Sandoval, even five months after their separation....
Cleverly argues that the United Kingdom and China need to have “pragmatic” working relations.: At a meeting with top Chinese officials in Beijing, British Foreign Secretary James Cleverly claimed that the UK was “clear-eyed” about the fact that Beijing...
Rick Edwards argues radio stations need to change as the new host of Fighting Talk: Before taking over as host of BBC Radio 5’s Fighting Talk, Rick Edwards stated it was “imperative” for stations to change and feature fresh voices....
Gilgo Beach killings: Rex Heuermann and former police chief James Burke may have met while “gay cruising,” argues the attorney for the victims: Rex Heuermann, a suspect in the Gilgo Beach killings, and former police chief James Burke, who mishandled the case, may have met while “gay cruising,”...
Institute of Race Relations (IRR) Argues State Capture Prosecutions Insufficient in Tackling Systemic Corruption: Evaluating Anti-Corruption Measures: The Institute of Race Relations (IRR) voices skepticism on the effectiveness of relying solely on State Capture prosecutions to combat widespread corruption...