Keir Starmer appoints Dame Antonia Romeo as first female head of the Civil Service in London amid past bullying allegations and scrutiny over New York tenure

In a landmark move for British politics, Sir Keir Starmer has appointed Dame Antonia Romeo as Cabinet Secretary and head of the Civil Service, marking the first time a woman has held the role in over 110 years.

The decision, however, comes amid renewed scrutiny over past allegations of bullying and questions about her time in previous positions.

A Career Built on Public Service

Dame Antonia, currently serving as the permanent secretary of the Home Office, brings more than 25 years of experience in the public sector.

Sir Keir praised her as “an outstanding public servant” whose professionalism and determination have impressed him since he became Prime Minister.

Speaking after her appointment, Dame Antonia expressed her commitment to the Civil Service.

“We should be known for delivery, efficiency, and innovation,” she said, emphasizing the importance of implementing the government’s agenda and addressing the challenges facing the country.

The Shadow of Past Controversies

The appointment has reignited debate over Dame Antonia’s conduct in previous roles, particularly during her tenure as consul-general in New York in 2017.

At that time, she faced accusations of bullying, but a formal investigation by the Cabinet Office cleared her, stating there was “no case to answer.”

Details from the complaints suggested that some colleagues believed she prioritized her personal profile over her work.

She was also publicly criticised by former diplomat Lord McDonald of Salford, who cautioned No10 against her appointment.

Allies, however, argue these criticisms are fueled by misogyny and resentment toward her unorthodox approach to civil service leadership.

Questions Over Travel and Expenses

Dame Antonia’s time in New York also drew attention for financial reasons.

Reports revealed she commuted between New York and London at taxpayer expense, though she later repaid tens of thousands of pounds after officials raised concerns.

She also hosted high-profile social events at her official residence, including gatherings attended by fashion icon Dame Anna Wintour and actress Dame Joanna Lumley.

Government officials stated that her travel and accommodation arrangements were within standard processes at the time and that repayment was voluntary.

Breaking the Mold in the Civil Service

Her appointment replaces Sir Chris Wormald, who stepped down amid controversy over Lord Mandelson’s ambassadorial nomination to the United States.

Dame Antonia’s allies defend her record, highlighting the challenges she faced as an outsider in traditionally elite Foreign Office circles.

One source described the criticism as “internal jealousy” from those who were passed over for key positions, while another noted that she has consistently achieved results by taking a different approach to conventional civil service methods.

What’s Next?

Dame Antonia will now oversee one of the UK’s most influential institutions, guiding the Civil Service through ongoing political challenges and major policy implementations.

Observers will be watching how she balances reform, efficiency, and inclusivity while navigating the legacy of past controversies.

Her leadership style and decisions are expected to set a precedent for future Cabinet Secretaries, especially women in senior public roles.

Summary

Dame Antonia Romeo’s appointment as the first female Cabinet Secretary marks a historic moment in UK governance.

While celebrated for her 25-year public service record and proven results, her past controversies—ranging from bullying claims to high-profile social events and travel expenses—have sparked debate.

Allies insist her critics are motivated by jealousy and misogyny, while Sir Keir Starmer emphasizes her professionalism and capacity to deliver results.

Her tenure will now be closely watched as she leads the Civil Service into a new era of reform and innovation.