As immigration crackdowns ramp up under President Trump’s administration, a growing number of Catholic leaders are stepping forward to voice their unease—especially about the impact on families and communities. U.S. bishops are saying loud and clear: simply enforcing the law isn’t enough.
The human cost, they argue, is too high to ignore.
A Call for Balance, Not Just Enforcement
Archbishop Timothy Broglio, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, spoke on behalf of his fellow bishops in a strong statement addressing the recent surge in immigration-related arrests.
While acknowledging that maintaining order and safety is part of the government’s duty, he made it clear that this wave of arrests is going too far.
“These actions are not just targeting people with criminal records,” he said.
“They’re impacting everyday people—our neighbors, our coworkers, our parishioners—simply because of their immigration status.
This kind of widespread enforcement, especially when it bypasses due process, tears at the heart of our communities.”
A Message of Solidarity and Support
Broglio’s message wasn’t just about criticism—it was also deeply pastoral.
He offered reassurance and comfort to those caught in the middle of this national debate.
“To all those affected by these raids and removals, know that your bishops and your pastors stand with you,” he said.
“We will not turn away during this painful time.”
Condemning Violence While Defending Peaceful Protest
The archbishop also acknowledged the wave of protests happening across the country in response to the enforcement actions.
While he recognized the value of public dissent, he drew a firm line against violent responses.
“Yes, protesting is a democratic right,” he said.
“But violence undermines that right and distracts from the very real issues at hand.
We must speak up, but we must do so peacefully.”
Defending Catholic Charities and Care Providers
Another growing concern raised by the bishops is the rising criticism aimed at Catholic-run service agencies.
Some voices have accused these organizations of enabling illegal immigration, but Broglio pushed back strongly.
“Every day, Catholic charities serve the most vulnerable among us,” he said.
“These baseless accusations not only damage their work—they also fuel division and fear at a time when we need unity.”
A Plea for Compassionate Solutions
In closing, Archbishop Broglio made a heartfelt plea for change—not just in policy, but in mindset.
He emphasized the need for immigration reform that is fair, respectful, and compassionate.
“Our immigration system is broken, but the answer can’t be cruelty,” he said.
“We need solutions that are just and humane, and the bishops of this country are ready to be part of that conversation.
We want to help find a better way forward.”