The abrupt expulsion of South African Ambassador Ebrahim Rasool from the United States over the weekend has left South Africa reeling.
The move has sparked widespread concern about the future of SA-US relations, with many questioning what this means for diplomatic ties under the Trump administration.
During a panel discussion hosted by Newsroom Afrika, experts painted a grim picture, suggesting that repairing relations between the two nations may not be an easy task.
Rasool to Brief President Ramaphosa on the Fallout
With Rasool set to return to South Africa by Friday, all eyes are on how the government will respond to this diplomatic upheaval.
The Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO) confirmed on Monday that they are already working to find a replacement for the ambassador.
Upon his return, Rasool is expected to brief President Cyril Ramaphosa and DIRCO Minister Ronald Lamola on the events that led to his expulsion.
He will also provide an update on his efforts to improve relations between the two nations, especially in light of Trump’s accusations that South Africa discriminates against the Afrikaner community and does not align with US international interests.
Finding the Right Successor
The question of who will replace Rasool has sparked debate among South Africans, with names like former DIRCO Minister Naledi Pandor and Economic Freedom Fighters leader Julius Malema being floated as potential candidates. However, not everyone is convinced that familiar faces are the solution.
International relations expert Thembisa Fakude dismissed the idea of bringing in former officials, stating, “Recycling old talent won’t work for us.”
Fakude also criticized Rasool for making public statements about the Trump administration, emphasizing that South Africa needs to be more strategic in its diplomatic approach.
Political economist Lebohang Pheko weighed in on the qualities needed in Rasool’s successor, stating that the next ambassador must possess “gravitas and wisdom” while also being skilled in balancing diplomacy with assertiveness.
Pheko suggested that the new envoy should adopt President Ramaphosa’s “soft-soft” style but must also be firm in protecting South Africa’s interests.
Can South Africa Engage the US Under Trump?
Some experts argue that maintaining constructive engagement with the US will be nearly impossible as long as Trump remains in office.
International relations professor John Stremlau believes that South Africa should shift its focus elsewhere, advising, “Just wait out the storm and get on with it.”
While acknowledging the economic importance of US ties, Stremlau suggested that South Africa should strengthen its relationships with other global partners, particularly within Africa and the BRICS alliance.
Pheko echoed this sentiment, urging the country to take a “South-Africa-first” approach and actively pursue opportunities in Africa and beyond.
Looking Beyond America
The expulsion of Rasool has raised critical questions about South Africa’s foreign policy direction.
Should the country continue attempting to mend relations with the US, or is it time to prioritize partnerships elsewhere?
As Pheko put it, “America is important, but it doesn’t have to be the beginning and the end of the world.”