A recent study conducted by researchers from the University of Cambridge has shed light on how men with certain regional accents are perceived, particularly in relation to criminal behavior.
According to the research, men with accents from places such as Liverpool and Bradford are often viewed as more likely to commit crimes.
This has raised concerns about how accents could potentially influence judgments in the criminal justice system.
The Perception of Accents in the UK
The study focused on how different regional accents in the UK are perceived by the public.
Researchers used recordings of men speaking English in ten different accents: Belfast, Birmingham, Bradford, Bristol, Cardiff, Glasgow, Liverpool, Cockney, Newcastle, and received pronunciation (RP).
RP, commonly associated with the southern English upper classes, was ranked highest in wealth and confidence.
It was also perceived as the least likely to be linked with criminal activity such as physical assault, shoplifting, or dangerous driving.
On the other hand, working-class accents, such as those from Liverpool and Bradford, were more frequently associated with criminal behavior.
These findings are concerning, as they highlight the potential bias that individuals with these accents might face, especially in situations involving the criminal justice system.
The Impact on the Criminal Justice System
Lead researcher Alice Paver emphasized that the study highlights the “disadvantage” faced by speakers of certain accents, particularly in legal contexts.
She pointed out that police officers, lawyers, and juries may unintentionally judge voices based on stereotypes, which could influence their decisions.
“As things stand, listeners think some accents sound guiltier than others, and we should all be concerned about that,” Paver explained.
The study involved 180 participants from across the UK who were asked to rate various accents based on class and personality traits.
They also rated how likely they thought the individuals with these accents were to commit specific crimes, such as assault or defending a victim of harassment.
Regional Accents and Stereotypes
While some accents, like those from Belfast, Birmingham, Cardiff, and Glasgow, were associated with qualities such as kindness, honesty, and friendliness, others—such as Scouse (Liverpool)—were linked to more negative perceptions, including the likelihood of committing infidelity or assault.
Interestingly, RP was ranked higher when it came to sexual assault, just behind Cockney and Liverpool accents.
This suggests a shift in perceptions regarding the types of men associated with sexual offenses, which is a notable trend for researchers to monitor.
Addressing Accent Bias in the Legal System
Paver’s team is now working on drafting guidelines for police officers, lawyers, judges, and juries to address the issue of voice bias in legal proceedings.
They also support pre-testing to help screen for voice-related prejudice.
“These stereotypes could have real-life legal consequences,” Paver warned.
The study is a stark reminder of how ingrained biases based on accents can affect real-world outcomes, especially in the context of law and justice.
This article was published on TDPel Media. Thanks for reading!Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn