Patrice Evra Calls Out Scholes Neville and Keane for Trying to Kill Michael Carrick Future at Manchester United

Manchester United legend Patrice Evra has spoken out fiercely against his former teammates turned pundits, Paul Scholes, Gary Neville, and Roy Keane, accusing them of trying to “kill” Michael Carrick’s managerial career.

Evra, who won five Premier League titles with United, made it clear he believes these former stars are unfairly undermining Carrick as he steps into one of football’s most high-pressure jobs.

Evra Defends Carrick and Questions Critics’ Credibility

Speaking to Stake, Evra expressed disbelief at the negativity Carrick is facing.

“I really don’t understand the lack of support behind Michael Carrick.

He’s one of us, and he’s doing very well,” Evra said.

He didn’t hold back when referencing his former teammates’ managerial struggles.

“Most of these guys get a managerial job and get fired straight away.

As players, they’re legends, but as managers, they haven’t done a great job.

For them to speak and possibly kill the career of a manager is a little bit too much.”

Evra even poked fun at Neville’s infamous stint at Valencia, joking, “They asked for paella, and you gave them fish and chips.”

Former Pundits Criticize Carrick’s Lack of Experience

The criticism from Scholes, Neville, and Keane largely revolves around Carrick’s managerial experience.

Carrick, 44, has impressed since stepping in after Ruben Amorim, winning six of his first eight games.

Despite his strong start, Scholes recently slammed United on Instagram after a defeat to Newcastle, calling the team “c**p” in the last four games, before quickly deleting the post.

Neville has suggested United “pursue another manager” to reduce risk, citing previous attempts with young ex-players like Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.

Keane has remained consistently skeptical, stating that even if Carrick finished strong, he wouldn’t consider him the permanent choice.

Carrick’s Record Speaks for Itself

While criticism persists, Carrick’s results are impressive.

He has guided United through a tough period, with six wins out of eight matches, showing tactical awareness and calm leadership.

Many fans and former players, including Evra, argue this demonstrates he deserves support and patience.

Impact and Consequences

Evra’s comments bring added pressure on Scholes, Neville, and Keane, highlighting the tension between ex-players in media roles and current managers.

The ongoing debate could influence how United’s board and fans perceive Carrick’s prospects for a permanent position.

What’s Next?

Manchester United will continue assessing Carrick’s performance as the season progresses.

Any decision on a permanent managerial appointment will likely consider results, player morale, and whether the club wants an experienced outside manager or to back a club insider.

Summary

Patrice Evra has launched a fiery defense of Michael Carrick against former Manchester United stars turned pundits.

Scholes, Neville, and Keane have publicly questioned Carrick’s experience, but Evra argues their managerial track records are too weak to justify such criticism.

Carrick’s early success as interim manager remains a strong case for backing him.

Bulleted Takeaways

• Patrice Evra criticizes Scholes, Neville, and Keane for attacking Michael Carrick.
• Carrick has won six of eight matches as Manchester United interim manager.
• Scholes called United “c**p” after a defeat, sparking controversy.
• Neville and Keane stress Carrick lacks experience for a permanent role.
• Evra highlights the former players’ poor managerial records to question their authority.
• Debate may influence United’s decision on Carrick’s permanent appointment.