Mellisa Roskosky, PhD*,1,2; Brian F. Borah, MD*,1,3; Peter M. DeJonge, PhD1,4; Catherine V. Donovan, PhD5; Lynn Zanardi Blevins, MD3; Allison G. Lafferty, MD3; Julia C. Pringle, PhD6; Patsy Kelso, PhD3; Jonathan L. Temte, MD7; Emily Temte7; Shari Barlow7; Maureen Goss, MPH7; Amra Uzicanin, MD8; Allen Bateman, PhD9; Kelsey Florek, PhD9; Vance Kawakami, DVM2; James Lewis, MD2; Julie Loughran2; Sargis Pogosjans, MPH2; Meagan Kay, DVM2; Jeff Duchin, MD2; Stephanie Lunn, MPH, MS10; Hannah Schnitzler, DVM10; Shivani Arora5; Jacqueline Tate, PhD11; Jessica Ricaldi, MD11; Hannah Kirking, MD11 (View author affiliations)
Ten patients with early reinfections were identified (Table). WGS identified Delta variant in all specimens from first infections and Omicron in all reinfection specimens.*** Median age at first infection was 11 years. Eight patients were aged <18 years, one was a long-term care facility resident, and one was a health care worker†††; five were male. Intervals between initial and subsequent specimen collections ranged from 23 to 87 days (median = 54.5 days). Patient E had completed a 2-dose mRNA COVID-19 vaccination series 6–10 weeks before the first infection; patients A and B each had received a single dose of mRNA COVID-19 vaccine between infections. The seven remaining patients were unvaccinated. In Wisconsin, household transmission during patient G’s reinfection likely resulted in reinfections of patients F and H.§§§,¶¶¶ Nine patients were symptomatic during first infection (median duration = 9 days; range = 0–20 days).**** Among eight patients with available clinical data during reinfection, six were symptomatic during reinfection (median duration = 5 days; range = 0–10 days).
Expansion of SARS-CoV-2 WGS, through public health surveillance and longitudinal research,†††† might enable rapid identification of reinfections with distinct lineages and detection of novel variants. Current CDC guidance for identifying early reinfections requires demonstration of different lineages by genetic sequencing.§§§§ Limited capacity for strain testing, including WGS, diminishes opportunities for first and reinfection NAAT specimens from the same person to undergo additional testing.¶¶¶¶ Moreover, antigen tests are increasingly performed at home, resulting in specimens being unavailable for strain testing. Thus, most early reinfections are likely not identified.
The findings from this case series might not be generalizable to the U.S. population and are specific to the transition period between Delta and Omicron variant predominance. Nonetheless, this study highlights potential limits of infection-induced immunity against novel variants.
One patient in this case series had received a full primary COVID-19 vaccine series but was not yet eligible for a booster. No other eligible patient was up to date on recommended COVID-19 vaccinations,***** which provides additional protection, even among those with previous infection (2,5). These patients might have had increased risk for SARS-CoV-2 infection because of low vaccination rates††††† and high rates of close contact§§§§§ in school-aged cohorts, and higher frequency and intensity of exposures in health care and congregate settings. Although the epidemiology of COVID-19 might change as new variants emerge, vaccination remains the safest strategy for preventing future SARS-CoV-2 infections (2,5).