Los Angeles judge slams Hollywood producer David Pearce for attempting to turn murder trial into a spectacle during his testimony

The trial of former Hollywood producer David Pearce has become a spectacle, drawing attention for its shocking allegations and tense exchanges.

Accused of murdering two women—model Christy Giles and architect Hilda Cabrales-Arzola—Pearce’s decision to testify against his lawyer’s advice turned the courtroom into a dramatic battleground.

Judge Eleanor Hunter, presiding over the case, rebuked Pearce for his attempt to dominate proceedings.

“You just want to narrate your version,” Hunter declared, emphasizing that she wouldn’t allow the trial to devolve into theatrics.

Her comments referenced Pearce’s alleged manipulative tactics, including a reported jailhouse call to his mother in which he discussed orchestrating a mistrial.

The Fatal Night in Question

On November 14, 2021, Giles and Cabrales-Arzola were found unconscious after attending a party at Pearce’s apartment.

Surveillance footage reportedly captured Pearce carrying their limp bodies to his car before they were abandoned at separate hospitals.

While Giles was already dead, Cabrales-Arzola died days later after falling into a coma.

Toxicology reports revealed a lethal mix of drugs, including fentanyl and GHB, in their systems.

Prosecutors accuse Pearce of administering the drugs, but he denies these claims, stating the women were “active drug users” before arriving at his home.

His defense maintains that Pearce brought them to the hospital believing they were still alive.

A History of Alleged Abuse

Beyond the murder charges, Pearce faces accusations of sexual assault from seven other women over a span of 13 years.

His testimony described hosting alcohol- and drug-fueled parties with women he met through dating apps.

He admitted to providing cocaine and engaging in sexual activities but characterized these encounters as consensual.

Several women, referred to by pseudonyms, have detailed experiences of assault and coercion.

One accuser, “Jane Doe 6,” claimed she blacked out after consuming drugs provided by Pearce and later realized she had been assaulted.

Pearce, however, described her as a willing participant who continued visiting his apartment.

Deception and Double Lives

The trial has also revealed a pattern of deceit in Pearce’s past.

Testimony from his ex-girlfriend, Karla Reyes, painted a picture of a loving, protective partner.

However, under cross-examination, Reyes learned of Pearce’s history of impersonating a doctor, using fake IDs, and issuing threats via text messages.

These revelations shook her perception of him as an honest person.

Prosecutors presented additional evidence, including Pearce’s web searches on fleeing to non-extradition countries and “disappearing.”

These searches occurred shortly after the women’s deaths, raising questions about his intentions.

The Road Ahead

As the trial unfolds, the jury will weigh testimonies, evidence, and Pearce’s history of alleged manipulation.

His defense argues he is being vilified for his lifestyle, while prosecutors frame him as a calculating predator.

The case, already gripping public attention, continues to shed light on a darker side of Hollywood’s party scene and raises broader questions about power, privilege, and accountability.

What happens next in this high-profile trial remains to be seen.