Lions Leadership Rethinks Selection Priorities and Reshapes the Roster as They Prepare to Confront Their Rivals in a Determined Tour of Australia

England’s impressive finish in the Six Nations has seen a surge in the number of Steve Borthwick’s players entering the Lions conversation.

With their strong showing, many more names have emerged as potential call-ups compared to before the Championship kicked off.

It’s a clear reminder that brilliant performances can suddenly elevate a player’s status on the international stage.

The Fly-Half Conundrum

When it comes to orchestrating the attack from No 10, my mind is set on a Scot—Finn Russell remains my top pick to lead the charge.

Early in 2025, most pundits were split between Russell and Marcus Smith as the main candidates for the role.

However, the debate has since exploded into a more complex contest.

Weighing the Fly-Half Options

Marcus Smith spent a considerable part of the Six Nations at full-back, which paved the way for Fin Smith to shine in a more consistent role.

Fin’s composed performances make him a prime understudy to Russell.

Then there’s Sam Prendergast, who burst onto the scene with Ireland in brilliant fashion before his form dipped a bit.

For me, the decision on who should command the fly-half role narrows down to Russell, Prendergast, and the two Smiths.

While both Marcus Smith and Russell are known for their unpredictable flair, Fin Smith offers a calm, controlled alternative with his excellent passing game.

Prendergast, though occasionally questioned for his defence, more than makes up for it with his superb playmaking skills.

Beyond the Fly-Halves: Strategic Squad Choices

The versatility of Marcus Smith means that he, along with Fin Smith, Russell, and Prendergast, could all potentially feature in the final touring party, depending on its size.

France’s Six Nations victory has highlighted the depth of talent across the Home Nations, a development that should bring a smile to Andy Farrell’s face.

Despite minimal representation from Wales, their standout captain Jac Morgan is almost guaranteed a spot, as his leadership in the highly competitive back row is invaluable.

Controversies and Key Selections

One contentious issue is the situation with Jack Willis, whose remarkable form in France over the past two years makes him a natural choice.

Yet, due to his club commitments with Toulouse, he remains ineligible for international play—a situation that continues to frustrate many.

Alongside him, Scotland’s Blair Kinghorn, who is also tied up with Toulouse, deserves inclusion in the Test team regardless of any early absences.

As a coach, it’s all about choosing the best players available, and both Willis and Kinghorn have that undeniable quality.

Setting Up the Forwards and Leadership Dynamics

Looking further into the squad, I’d deploy Willis at blindside flanker, pair him with Caelan Doris at No 8, and opt for either Jac Morgan or Tom Curry on the openside.

Curry, in particular, has been sensational throughout the Six Nations and currently seems to be winning the battle in his position.

Leadership remains key—whether Doris or Maro Itoje dons the captain’s armband, I’m confident either will excel and steer the team effectively.

National Balance and Final Thoughts

Other players making strong cases include Will Stuart, Fin Smith, Ben Earl, and Curry—all of whom have shown why they deserve a Lions cap after several stellar weeks.

At tighthead prop, Stuart has grown into a formidable force and could well challenge Scotland’s Zander Fagerson, especially as Tadhg Furlong struggles with fitness.

In the backline, I’m excited to see Scots like Russell and Kinghorn leading the charge, supported by a potent centre pairing of Sione Tuipulotu and Huw Jones.

Jones, in particular, has been in excellent form, and once Tuipulotu recovers from injury, his presence will be a significant boost against Australia.

Injury concerns linger with England wing Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, who I hope will recover in time to be considered for selection, while Tommy Freeman has impressed with his consistent scoring, suggesting he might be better suited long term at outside centre rather than on the wing.

Ireland’s Mack Hansen is also expected to join the squad, ready to take on the challenge with enthusiasm.

Looking Ahead: The Final Squad Vision

The team heading to Australia is set to be a balanced mix of pace and power—five Englishmen, six Irish, and four Scots—with Wales offering minimal representation aside from Morgan.

The impending contest between Curry and Morgan is shaping up to be one of the most intriguing match-ups to watch.

All in all, a projected Lions Test team for Australia might feature Blair Kinghorn; Tommy Freeman, Huw Jones, Sione Tuipulotu, James Lowe; Finn Russell, Jamison Gibson-Park; Andrew Porter, Dan Sheehan, Will Stuart, Maro Itoje, Tadhg Beirne, Jack Willis, Tom Curry, and Caelan Doris as captain.

What comes next is the unfolding journey of one of rugby’s most compelling tours, and I can’t wait to see how it all plays out.