The deadly courthouse shooting that rocked Letcher County last month has continued to stir intense media attention and speculation.
Sheriff Shawn “Mickey” Stines, accused of killing District Judge Kevin Mullins in his own chambers on September 19, remains in custody, and now his family is stepping forward to clear up lingering rumors.
Denying Allegations About Stines’ Daughter
Following the shooting, whispers spread that Mullins had some kind of connection with Stines’ minor daughter, as her phone number appeared in his phone.
Both Caroline Stines and her daughter have firmly denied these claims, telling Kentucky State Police detectives that no relationship ever existed between Mullins, a married father of two, and the young girl.
Detective Clayton Stamper confirmed during grand jury testimony that there was no evidence of contact between Mullins and the minor through texts, social media, calls, or in person.
He did note that Stines used Mullins’ phone to call his daughter moments before the shooting, as captured in security footage, but it’s unclear if anyone answered.
A Disturbing Glimpse Into Stines’ Mental State
Court records released prior to being sealed reveal more about Stines’ mental health immediately after the incident.
A medical report from Leslie County Detention Center staff dated September 23 indicated that Stines remained in a state of “active psychosis” days after the shooting.
Staff noted he was disoriented and had no recollection of recent events, only aware of information relayed to him by jail personnel.
Walking Past Deputies After the Shooting
Eyewitness accounts paint a chilling scene at the courthouse that day.
When deputies arrived to search for an active shooter, Stines reportedly walked past them with a “blank look” on his face.
At least one deputy asked where the shooter was, and Stines offered no immediate response. Moments later, he admitted, “There’s nobody else.
It’s me,” before placing his pistol on the table.
Troubling Allegations About Mullins
In the wake of the shooting, further disturbing claims about Judge Mullins have surfaced.
One witness alleged that Mullins “ran his chambers like a brothel” and was observed engaging in sexual activity in his office.
Stines and Mullins were longtime friends and regulars at a local sports bar, often sharing lunch together—on the day of the shooting, they both ordered their usual $13.99 wings with salad.
Trial Timeline and Custody Status
The start date for Stines’ murder trial remains uncertain, as prosecutors have indicated that the discovery process could take “some time.”
For now, Stines continues to be held in custody without bond, as the investigation and court proceedings move forward.