When people think of a traditional British pub, they picture roast dinners, hearty pints, and maybe a bit of The Beatles or some classic British rock in the background.

So, when visitors step into Jeremy Clarkson’s pub—The Farmer’s Dog in Oxfordshire—they expect exactly that.

But some customers are finding that while the food screams Britain, the music seems to be coming from across the Atlantic.

Proudly British on the Plate… Not So Much Through the Speakers

The Farmer’s Dog has built its reputation on being unapologetically British.

The menu highlights ingredients sourced entirely from UK farms—like lamb and venison—giving it a farm-to-fork appeal that matches Clarkson’s love for local agriculture.

Even its branding leans heavily on national pride.

But there’s a twist.

On the pub’s own website, Clarkson jokes about not quite pulling off a “British” gin and tonic and admits that modern pub-goers expect things like avocado and Coca-Cola.

Still, visitors weren’t quite prepared for what they say was a full-on American musical takeover.

Customers Call Out the “Yankee Doodle” Soundtrack

A few guests took to social media to voice their disappointment.

One X (formerly Twitter) user, James Milligan, shared: “Amazing birthday weekend in the Cotswolds, visited Jeremy Clarkson’s The Farmer’s Dog which prides itself on being 100% British.

Food was unreal, but please change the music to suit.

Spent the two hours I was there listening to American themed music.”

He finished the post with the hashtag #notbritish.

Another customer echoed the sentiment, noting the lack of ketchup and coffee—but more notably, the complete absence of British music.

“Plenty [of British artists] out there,” they pointed out, adding that despite the music mismatch, the food was still worth coming back for.

A Touch of Irony from Clarkson’s Past

It’s hard not to chuckle at the irony, given Clarkson’s long-running jokes about American culture.

Longtime fans might remember a Top Gear segment where he drove through Alabama with a car plastered with the slogan: “Country and western music is rubbish.”

Now, years later, guests are eating British gammon steak while listening to—you guessed it—country and western tunes.

The Farmer’s Dog, renamed by Clarkson after buying and renovating a local spot previously known as The Windmill, sits near his Diddly Squat farm and pays homage to his pets and agricultural passions.

So, the decision to play American music in a pub deeply rooted in British pride? It’s left some scratching their heads.

Pricey or Worth It? The Roast Debate Heats Up

While the music stirred one kind of debate, the price tag of a Sunday roast stirred another.

One visitor recently posted a photo of her £174 bill on social media after dining at The Farmer’s Dog on June 8.

The tab covered six roast dinners, drinks, sides, and a service charge.

Despite the steep total, she had glowing words for the experience: “Went to The Farmer’s Dog yesterday, what a lovely experience.

Very busy but once we were in, the atmosphere was relaxed, the food was delicious, and staff were brilliant.

Great price for 6 roast dinners and drinks. Highly recommend.”

Not everyone agreed.

The Internet Chimes In: Overpriced or Just Right?

The receipt sparked a flurry of comments. One critic took issue with the added service charge, arguing: “Why add a service charge?

Walking food from kitchen to table is the same whether the meal costs £10 or £100. Just include it in the price.”

Another person wasn’t thrilled with the drink prices, pointing out: “£7 for a pint is a bit excessive.”

And then came the Sunday roast purist who complained: “Looks great, but £24 for a Sunday lunch should include the Yorkshire pud.”

So, What’s Next for Clarkson’s Pub?

The Farmer’s Dog is clearly making waves—both good and bad.

The food has earned rave reviews, and many diners say they’ll be back despite the quirks.

But whether Clarkson will swap out the Americana playlist for something more Britpop remains to be seen.

One thing’s for sure: between the delicious roasts and the musical whiplash, The Farmer’s Dog isn’t your average country pub—and that’s exactly how Clarkson probably likes it.