Friday’s episode of Good Morning Britain became unexpectedly lively when wildlife campaigner Chris Packham revealed the unusual diet of his dogs, Sid and Nancy.
Hosts Kate Garraway, 58, and Ranvir Singh, 48, were back in the studio to discuss the latest headlines, but it was Chris’s comments about his pets’ plant-based meals that truly captured viewers’ attention.
Vegan Diet for Dogs: What It Means
Chris explained that his two dogs follow a strictly vegan diet.
According to the NHS, a vegan diet is “based on plants such as vegetables, grains, nuts, and fruits, and foods made from plants.”
This means Sid and Nancy do not consume meat, poultry, fish, dairy, or eggs.
Chris told Kate and Ranvir that recent research shows plant-based diets can be nutritionally as good as, or even better than, meat-based diets.
He referenced a 2022 systematic review of peer-reviewed studies and a similar study conducted last year by the University of Nottingham, both of which concluded that dogs on plant-based diets were healthier overall.
However, he was careful to note that this only works if the diet is properly formulated.
The Importance of Proper Formulation
Kate expressed her concern about the potential risks, saying that some people might opt for cheaper, poorly balanced diets that could harm their pets.
Chris reassured viewers, explaining that in the past, dog owners sometimes created their own diets at home, but his dogs’ meals had been developed in a lab.
What truly matters, he said, is not the source of the nutrients like proteins, amino acids, fats, or vitamins, but that they are present in the correct balance.
When a diet is formulated correctly, dogs can be just as healthy, if not healthier, than those on traditional meat-based diets.
Viewers Reacted Strongly on Social Media
Viewers at home took to X, formerly Twitter, to share their opinions, and many were not convinced.
Several argued that dogs need meat in their diets and that feeding them a vegan diet is unnatural.
Some commented that while they personally avoid meat, their dogs would never choose vegetables over meat.
Others questioned whether Chris might have financial interests in plant-based dog food.
The general sentiment among critics was that vegan diets for dogs are wrong and could be harmful if not carefully managed.
Veterinary Perspective: Balancing Health and Environment
Veterinarian Dr. Scott, 49, also joined the discussion to offer a professional perspective.
He acknowledged that plant-based diets can benefit the environment due to a lower carbon footprint, but emphasized that dogs are naturally omnivores.
When asked if dogs would normally eat both meat and plants, he explained that in the wild, dogs often consume some plant matter while digesting the carcass of an animal they have hunted, which shows they are designed to handle a mix of nutrients.
Chris Explains Why Vegan Dogs Can Work
Chris added further context, noting that dogs descend from wolves, which are carnivores, but have historically consumed vegetable matter for tens of thousands of years.
As omnivores, dogs are capable of digesting plant-based foods.
He stressed that the key factor is not whether the food comes from meat or plants, but whether the diet provides the right nutrients.
If a vegan diet is carefully supplemented to provide all the necessary proteins and other essentials, research shows that dogs can thrive.
Chris concluded that it is ultimately humans who must rethink what is best for their pets’ health.
Catch Good Morning Britain
Good Morning Britain airs weekdays from 6 a.m. on ITV1 and is available to stream on ITVX for viewers who want to watch the full discussion.
Share on Facebook «||» Share on Twitter «||» Share on Reddit «||» Share on LinkedIn