CBS News Editor-in-Chief Bari Weiss pulls El Salvador prison segment sparking internal backlash and debate over journalistic standards in the United States

CBS News Editor-in-Chief Bari Weiss has sparked controversy after choosing to pull a segment highlighting the “brutal and torturous” conditions at a prison in El Salvador, where the Trump administration has deported undocumented immigrants.

The decision came during CBS’s typical 9 a.m. editorial call on Monday, with Weiss telling colleagues the piece “did not advance the ball,” according to The New York Times.

Weiss emphasized the need for fresh, thought-provoking content, noting that other outlets—including the Times itself—had already reported on similar topics.

She argued that running the story two months later required additional reporting to meet her editorial standards.

Morning Joe Panel Criticizes the Move

The decision was met with strong pushback from MSNBC’s Morning Joe panel.

Host Joe Scarborough called it “an affront to journalism,” while co-host Mika Brzezinski described the prison conditions as “a living hell,” vouching for the accuracy of the reporting.

60 Minutes correspondent Sharyn Alfonsi, who produced the segment, also confirmed that the story had cleared CBS’s rigorous standards review five times before Weiss decided to hold it.

Internal Tensions Rise at CBS

Inside CBS, Weiss’s choice has caused significant unrest.

Sources told CNN that staff threatened to quit over the move, which occurred after the story had already been fully vetted by lawyers and researchers.

Suggested Readings (News continues below)

Chris Rea passes away at 74 leaving behind a legacy of Driving Home For Christmas and inspiring fans with his music and resilience in the UK

Barry Manilow Reveals Lung Cancer Diagnosis in the United States After MRI Discovers Spot on His Left Lung Following Bronchitis

David Walliams is removed as ambassador for The Children’s Trust in the United Kingdom following harassment allegations and charity review

Brooklyn Beckham blocks his parents David and Victoria and siblings Romeo, Cruz, and Harper on Instagram amid family feud in the United States

Contributor Pablo Torre criticized Weiss, claiming she is “not a reporter, not a journalist” and is “poisoning the well” of investigative reporting.

Alfonsi called the shelving of her story a form of censorship.

The segment focused on Venezuelan men who were deported to the Terrorism Confinement Center (CECOT) in El Salvador, believing they were returning to their home country.

Editorial Standards vs. Government Access

Weiss defended her decision to The New York Times, stating her responsibility is to ensure stories are “the best they can be.”

She noted that stories sometimes need to be folded because they lack context or critical voices, a routine practice in newsrooms.

CBS sources revealed that Weiss’s main concern was the lack of response from the Trump administration.

Alfonsi and her team had sought interviews with DHS, the White House, and the State Department, all of which declined.

Alfonsi argued that refusing interviews should not give officials a “kill switch” over reporting.

Background and Corporate Context

Weiss joined CBS after being hired by Paramount CEO David Ellison in October.

She is the founder of the right-leaning Free Press, purchased by Ellison for $150 million.

Ellison, 42, is the son of billionaire Larry Ellison, a known Trump ally, and became CEO following Paramount’s merger with Skydance earlier this year.

CBS has faced criticism in the past for editorial decisions, including settling a lawsuit with former President Trump over a 2024 60 Minutes interview he claimed was “deceptively” edited.

The timing of Weiss’s appointment and Paramount’s media expansion—including a hostile takeover bid for Warner Bros Discovery, which owns CNN—has raised questions about editorial independence and the network’s future direction.

The Story’s Fate Remains Unclear

Following Weiss’s statement, it is still unknown when the El Salvador prison segment will air.

CBS staff and viewers alike are left waiting to see if the investigative piece will ever reach the public, and whether the internal tensions sparked by the decision will have lasting effects on the newsroom’s morale and editorial credibility.