When it comes to tough topics like euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide, the conversation often stirs strong feelings.
Recently, Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York’s Archdiocese stepped forward to share his concerns with state lawmakers who are considering a bill that would legalize voluntary euthanasia in New York.
Saving Lives Should Be the Priority, Says Cardinal Dolan
In a heartfelt opinion piece for the Wall Street Journal, Cardinal Dolan urged lawmakers to focus on preventing suicide instead of creating legal pathways to end life.
He shared a vivid memory of seeing a man on the George Washington Bridge who was threatening to jump — a moment that highlighted how deeply people care and rally to save lives in crisis.
He wrote about how onlookers prayed and rescuers worked tirelessly to bring the man back from the brink, underscoring the importance of saving those struggling with suicidal thoughts.
Mental Health Efforts Already Underway in New York
Dolan also pointed out that the Archdiocese is active in running suicide prevention programs in schools, supporting young people who might be in distress.
Plus, the state itself has invested millions into suicide prevention and mental health under Governor Kathy Hochul’s leadership.
It’s because of these ongoing efforts that Dolan expressed shock that New York lawmakers might legalize euthanasia — not through a tragic leap from a bridge, but through a “poison cocktail” provided by doctors and pharmacists.
A Stark Contrast in How Society Treats Vulnerable Lives
He called attention to the contradiction he sees: the government works hard to save one desperate individual from suicide but might simultaneously decide that some lives — those with serious illness or disabilities — aren’t worth living.
Dolan compared the proposed law to handing vulnerable people a “loaded gun” and telling them to use it.
This powerful image highlights his deep concerns about the message such legislation sends about the value of life and care for the vulnerable.
Where the Bill Stands and Political Divisions
The euthanasia bill already passed the New York State Assembly last month by a vote of 81 to 67.
Most Democrats supported it, but more than 20 Democrats crossed party lines to join Republicans in opposing it.
Now, the legislation faces a tougher challenge in the Senate, where some Democrats remain hesitant, delaying a vote.
The debate continues to divide lawmakers as well as communities, with profound questions about ethics, compassion, and how best to support those facing end-of-life decisions.