Gary Neville’s quickly corrected Sky Sports comment during Manchester City’s dramatic win over Liverpool at Anfield sparks Arsenal fan conspiracy theories about the Premier League title race

Football fans don’t need much to set social media on fire.

Sometimes, all it takes is one quick sentence said live on air, and suddenly the internet is convinced it has uncovered something massive.

That’s exactly what happened when Gary Neville, working as a Sky Sports co-commentator, made a hastily corrected remark during Manchester City’s dramatic 2–1 win over Liverpool at Anfield.

What should have been a routine moment quickly spiraled into conspiracy chatter among some Arsenal supporters already feeling anxious about the title race.

The Match Was Already Packed With Late Chaos

The game itself was intense from start to finish, but it truly exploded in the closing moments.

City and Liverpool were locked in a fierce battle until deep into stoppage time.

Erling Haaland eventually scored the winner from the penalty spot, handing Manchester City a crucial victory.

Moments later, Dominik Szoboszlai was shown a red card in the 113th minute, adding even more drama and confusion.

With all the stoppages, VAR checks, and delays, fans were left wondering how much time was actually still left on the clock.

Neville’s Comment That Sparked the Reaction

Right after the red card, Neville tried to clarify the situation.

He initially said there were “15 seconds left in this game, by the way we’ve just been told,” before quickly correcting himself.

He explained that it wasn’t information being passed directly to them, but rather something they had overheard from the officials’ communication.

He made it clear the referee wasn’t speaking to the commentary team.

It was a small correction, but in the heat of a title race, small moments often get blown up into something much bigger.

Arsenal Fans Online Jumped Straight Into Suspicion

Almost instantly, some Arsenal fans on X began reacting as if Neville had accidentally revealed something scandalous.

One supporter even called it a “smoking gun,” suggesting Neville was somehow connected to referees or that the Premier League race was being manipulated.

It didn’t take long for the conversation to spiral into claims about broadcasters, VAR, and the integrity of the title race.

The Simple Reality Behind It All

What many people either forgot or ignored is that Sky Sports commentators can hear the communication between VAR officials and the referee.

This has been publicly known since 2024 and is now part of standard broadcasting practice.

Neville wasn’t receiving secret instructions, and he certainly wasn’t influencing decisions.

He was simply listening to the same audio feed that broadcasters are allowed access to.

Several fans quickly pushed back, pointing out how normal this is and questioning why anyone would think referees would take advice from a pundit sitting in a commentary box.

Broadcasters Confirmed It Was Completely Normal

The conspiracy was shut down further when broadcaster Rex Kirby explained that he worked on the match and personally heard the VAR feed, because broadcasters are able to monitor those communications.

Even Arsenal supporters watching overseas noted that American broadcasts, such as Peacock, openly mention when commentators can hear the discussion between officials.

In other words, nothing unusual was happening at all.

This Isn’t the First Time Arsenal Fans Have Felt Uneasy

This episode also reopened memories of last season, when Arsenal lost 2–0 to Bournemouth and William Saliba was sent off.

After that match, some fans claimed referee chief Howard Webb was influencing decisions because he was spotted in the stands wearing an earpiece and holding his phone.

Sky Sports presenter David Jones later clarified that Webb was simply listening to the same VAR communication feed that broadcasters receive.

He had no ability to speak to the officials or interfere with decisions.

It was monitoring, not meddling.

VAR Transparency Still Feels Messy to Fans

The deeper issue here isn’t Gary Neville’s wording. It’s that VAR remains a sensitive subject, and many supporters still feel the process lacks transparency.

The Premier League has taken steps toward more openness in recent years, but until fans can hear the same conversations officials are having in real time, suspicion will always find a way to grow, especially during a tense title race.

What’s next?

This won’t be the last time a split-second comment sparks outrage online.

As the title race continues, every refereeing decision, every VAR check, and every pundit remark will be magnified.

The Premier League may continue pushing toward greater transparency, but emotional fan reactions are unlikely to disappear anytime soon.

Summary

Gary Neville’s quickly corrected on-air comment during Manchester City’s win over Liverpool caused a social media storm among some Arsenal fans, who claimed it hinted at a “fixed” title race.

In reality, broadcasters have been allowed to hear VAR and referee communications since 2024, and multiple fans and broadcasters confirmed this is standard practice.

The episode reflects how fragile trust around officiating still is, and how easily small moments can ignite conspiracy theories when the stakes are high.